Not sure I agree. It might help that I buy the smaller sardines (as mentioned above) and combine them with acid. I just did a search and both of those things were recommended as ways to reduce odor. I also generally eat them at room temp rather than cooking them, which I'm sure makes a big difference in their smell. I also haven't had any complaints about my smell, but they'd be mostly from my family as I'm a remote worker... /shruggie
> I wonder if there anything similar without the smell?
Maybe salmon and mackerel? I think they're in the middle of the food chain (where sardines and tuna are more at the extremes) and similarly between in fat content.
> Honestly for the reasons you listed though sardines are kind of a super food imo.
Yeah, I think if sardines aren't a superfood, the word doesn't mean anything at all...
I like canned salmon as well, much less smell for sure but I figured it wasn't as healthy because of pollutants. Never tried mackerel. Found a chart and looks like, mackerel, salmon, herring, and sardines are all about the same. I've had the herring and it was good and similar price to sardines.
There are also some fish meal combo tins (salad toppers, really) I like, such as these: https://freshemeals.com/ My favorite is the Moroccan Tagine salmon. They're on clearance at my local grocery store for 50% off so I bought a few dozen...
iirc a physician advised my then-pregnant wife to have salmon at least twice a week, vs. the common recommendation to have tuna at most once a week.
I've also tried to get my RDA of Vitamin D every day. Often I get it from fortified (coconut) milk and a multi-vitamin. But I prefer to include fish. I'm particularly fond of canned sardines [1] because they're a long-shelf-life pantry item, they're a relatively inexpensive protein, they have lots of omega-3s and fit my low-carb diet, and (unlike tuna) they're low enough on the food chain that you can eat them daily without excess heavy metal intake, and iiuc they're a more sustainable fish option. I think sardines have a bad reputation for taste because people lump them in with anchovies, which can be incredibly salty and fishy. I find sardines to be much more mild and versatile. I find they taste best alongside acids (lemon juice, vinegar, tomato) and maybe creamy fats (avocado/guac, cream cheese). You can add them to salad, toast, pasta, pizza, or even just inside a bell pepper.
Here's a good simple recipe for someone trying sardines for the first time: https://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/alton-brown/sherried-sar...
[1] the tiny, two-layer per can kind