News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by simonsarris on Monday February 13, 2012 @04:54PM (#3587493)
As a state that's 49% nuclear power (New Hampshire) I really welcome this news. It almost seems too good to be true.

I hope we will someday be able to close down the single coal plant in my state (coal is 14% of NH power).

For all its faults I think Nuclear has gotten a bad reputation from an extremely small amount of catastrophes. Obviously those events are very salient in the public's mind, but it is worth remembering that coal plants are a catastrophe every single day.

There are lakes in New Hampshire with abnormally high mercury levels that have never been touched by humans save for testing the water. Coal from as far as Ohio give rise to uncomfortable asthma statistics. I know it won't be soon, but there's at least one technology I can't wait to shutter.

Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by lukifer on Monday February 13, 2012 @06:53PM (#3587914)
> it is worth remembering that coal plants are a catastrophe every single day.

In addition to CO2 levels, most people are unaware of how much radioactive material is released by burning coal, because it's spread out of over time rather than in a few big dramatic incidents.

Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by beloch on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @12:17AM (#3588751)
More people die mining coal each year than have died in Nuclear power plant accidents in the entire history of Nuclear power.

The Bhopal chemical plant disaster killed more people than all the nuclear power incidents in history combined. This plant manufactured pesticides.

Nuclear power is not completely risk free, but it's much safer than most people give it credit for. Anyone who would picket a nuclear power plant before a coal plant or a pesticide plant is an uninformed twit.

Nuclear power also promises to get much safer. China is currently testing thorium reactors based on Canada's CANDU design. Thorium reactors have several safety advantages over Uranium reactors, produce less waste with a shorter half-life, and do not produce weapons-grade fissionable materials as a byproduct. Thorium is far more abundant than Uranium to boot. If Iran went after Thorium based nuclear power Israel would be able to sleep more easily at night.

Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by PakG1 on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @12:44AM (#3588812)
More people die mining coal each year than have died in Nuclear power plant accidents in the entire history of Nuclear power. Just noting that to fairly compare apples to apples, you should compare stats of coal mining deaths and accidents to uranium mining deaths and accidents.
Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by Tuna-Fish on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @05:56AM (#3589501)
That statistic would be even more violently pro-nuclear -- you need to dig up roughly 20 000 times more coal than uranium to produce the similar amounts of energy, assuming a steam thermal coal plant and a light-water nuclear reactor. If you swap that light-water plant to an advanced heavy water plant like CANDU, that multiplier goes up to about 2 000 000 times. A fun fact: the extractable amount of energy in the trace radioactive elements (notably thorium) that is dug up with coal (and mostly distributed into the environment) is several times higher than the extractable energy content of the coal.
Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by Tuna-Fish on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @06:04AM (#3589514)
> More people die mining coal each year than have died in Nuclear power plant accidents in the entire history of Nuclear power.

And the miner deaths are completely insignificant part of the total death toll of coal. Most of the death toll comes from NOx and SO2 poisoning, and manifests in cancer and respiratory diseases. The total death toll is hard to tally, but it is typically estimated to be between 100k and 1M a year.

Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by r00fus on Monday February 13, 2012 @07:54PM (#3588091)
Have these new designs improved on water usage problems [1]?

Although I agree about the closure of coal plants, it seems nuclear still has water usage issues (cooling needs) and given the upcoming fresh-water crisis [2], wouldn't solar be a better bet?

[1] http://www.ucsusa.org/nuclear_power/nuclear_power_technology...

[2] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12291371

Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by Kadin on Monday February 13, 2012 @09:18PM (#3588325)
While there may be a fresh-water crisis on a global scale, that doesn't mean there is a shortage everywhere. There are lots of places where there are ample water supplies, and use of the water there doesn't really effect water availability in places where it's in short supply.

Also, you can cool a nuclear reactor with ocean water. Seabrook Station in NH is cooled this way, as are other reactors located on ocean coasts, presumably.

Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by toomuchtodo on Monday February 13, 2012 @09:26PM (#3588350)
You can also use the waste heat from a nuclear generation facility to desalinate water.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desalination

"In a December 26, 2007, opinion column in the The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, Nolan Hertel, a professor of nuclear and radiological engineering at Georgia Tech, wrote, "... nuclear reactors can be used ... to produce large amounts of potable water. The process is already in use in a number of places around the world, from India to Japan and Russia. Eight nuclear reactors coupled to desalination plants are operating in Japan alone ... nuclear desalination plants could be a source of large amounts of potable water transported by pipelines hundreds of miles inland..."[12]

A typical aircraft carrier in the U.S. military uses nuclear power to desalinate 400,000 US gallons (1,500,000 l; 330,000 imp gal) of water per day.[14]

Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by mindcrime on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @12:46PM (#3590940)
Also, you can cool a nuclear reactor with ocean water. Seabrook Station in NH is cooled this way, as are other reactors located on ocean coasts, presumably.

Progress Energy's Brunswick Nuclear Plant[1] in Southport, NC takes brackish water from near the mouth of the Cape Fear River as it's source of cooling water, then discharges it through a canal back into the Atlantic Ocean.

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brunswick_Nuclear_Generating_St...

Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by tptacek on Monday February 13, 2012 @08:52PM (#3588268)
Is solar feasible at the scale we're talking about? What's the $/kwh?
Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by ethereal on Monday February 13, 2012 @10:37PM (#3588511)
I have some experience with solar energy at the small scale (1-2 kwh arrays) and I can say that at the consumer level, the cost for a solar array is now dropping to roughly $0.50/watt. It's still nowhere near the scale/cost of nuclear/coal but it's definitely more feasible than it was ten years ago.

Using the figure of $0.50/watt, to construct a 50MW plant would cost $25 million for the panels alone; bring in the infrastructure, mounting, and remember that the panels lose roughly 10% of their capacity every ten years. Plus account for cloudy days (not as much of an issue in, say, Arizona) and you start to realize that solar isn't a very viable option.

It works really well at the consumer/personal/business level but fails horribly at large, centralized setups. For those about to mention the `good sunlight' requirement, I will provide some refutation for that: my panels are located such that there is a good 30-degree angle to the east the sun has to peak before the light reaches them. The only time that power becomes an issue is the three weeks either side of the winter solstice; at which point I have to start watching my power consumption and regulating computer use etc.

I've assembled the array (roughly 1.5KWh) over the past ten years or so; the cost has been small considering what the equivalent would have been to purchase electricity from the power grid.

I have rambled on for quite a while here, for which I apologize. I guess the TL;DR version is: I don't think solar is feasible at large scale, but it seems to be at a small scale in my own experience.

Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by pjscott on Monday February 13, 2012 @11:08PM (#3588563)
Is that price per watt of peak power production, or per watt of average power? Solar tends to have a fairly low capacity factor, which is important to include in economics calculations.
Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by ethereal on Monday February 13, 2012 @11:27PM (#3588608)
That is per watt of peak power production.
Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by icebraining on Monday February 13, 2012 @10:34PM (#3588501)
I'm not well informed, but according to John Quiggin[1], yes:

(PV is photovoltaics)

    the cost of PV has already fallen well below that of nuclear and
    is set to fall further. The average retail price of solar cells as
    monitored by the Solarbuzz group fell from $3.50/watt to $2.43/watt
    over the course of the year, and a decline to prices below $2.00/watt
    seems inevitable. For large-scale installations, prices below
    $1.00/watt are now common. In some locations, PV has reached
    grid parity, the cost at which it is competitive with coal or gas-fired
    generation. More generally, it is now evident that, given a carbon
    price of $50/ton, which would raise the price of coal-fired power by
    5c/kWh, solar PV will be cost-competitive in most locations.
http://nationalinterest.org/commentary/the-end-the-nuclear-r...

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Quiggin

Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by DennisP on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @09:43AM (#3590141)
Those are valid numbers as long as solar is backed up by fossil fuels or nuclear, but if you want use solar for most of your electric power, you have to take energy storage into account. That's a lot more expensive.
Re:First new U.S. nuclear reactors in decades approved by ams6110 on Monday February 13, 2012 @09:20PM (#3588331)
No.