News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit takes a new direction by sophacles on Monday February 13, 2012 @02:40PM (#3587029)
1. It isn't a slippery slope argument I am making. I am simply stating that when the rules change, people don't like it, for the mere fact of it. Whether or not the reason for their dislike is fallacious, a qualitative difference in an implicit or explicit agreement will affect the community experience, and will anger those who were happy under the previous arrangement.

2. If you want to argue about fallacies, perhaps you shouldn't do so with a strawman. I never defended r/jailbait or any of the other banned subreddits. I was simply pointing out that there are differences between "anything goes" and "walled garden" approaches to community building, and that both have strong positive results, and one is not necessarily better than the other. The level of disingenuity of your reply is up there with "presidential candidate". Get off your moral high horse and reply to my actual statements.

3. I never claimed reddit would be radically different - again: I was discussing people's reactions, not claiming them as reflections of fact. Another strawman (thats at least 2 in one post!)

4. Who the fuck are you to be that condescending? What value do you provide to the world that makes you able to dictate what matters and what I should observe?

Re:Reddit takes a new direction by ugh on Monday February 13, 2012 @02:59PM (#3587102)
I did reply to your actual statements.

I never claimed you defended pedos. Where did I do that exactly?

I was stating that feeling betrayed by this change makes no sense at all. I cannot fathom how one can possibly feel betrayed by such a change. That’s all. Can you explain that to me? Huh?

Re:Reddit takes a new direction by weavejester on Monday February 13, 2012 @03:40PM (#3587251)
As a third-party observer, I initially had the same reaction as sophacles, in that your comment appeared, at first, to be a strongly-worded straw-man argument.

However, now that I re-read it I can see your point, but your use of profanity and the general lack of civility in your comment obscured your argument. The tone of your comment was more like an accusation than a reasoned response, even if the content (minus the profanity) was not intended to be.

Re:Reddit takes a new direction by ugh on Monday February 13, 2012 @03:47PM (#3587271)
It was supposed to be an accusation. Some things deserve accusations. And profanities.

Sigh. I’m quite disillusioned about HN, actually. Not that it should surprise me, but damn. People here say the exact same things as on Reddit. If you squint a bit the reactions are the same. That doesn’t make me happy.

I do recognize that I can’t do many constructive things here (short of screaming at people) so I’m going to excuse myself from this thread. I won’t convince anyone anyway.

Re:Reddit takes a new direction by scott_s on Monday February 13, 2012 @03:54PM (#3587297)
The first statement of the actual Guidelines of HN is "Be civil." I find it strange that you're disillusioned with HN because your uncivil comment was not well received.
Re:Reddit takes a new direction by ugh on Monday February 13, 2012 @03:59PM (#3587312)
(Just to clarify: I'm not disillusioned about karma or anything petty like that. I’m ok with being downvoted for not being civil. I’m disillusioned about the general attitude displayed here. That attitude made me want to not be civil anymore.)
Re:Reddit takes a new direction by epochwolf on Monday February 13, 2012 @04:25PM (#3587402)
> That attitude made me want to not be civil anymore.

Then it would be a good idea to take a break, maybe go for a walk, until you can be civil.

Re:Reddit takes a new direction by Karunamon on Monday February 13, 2012 @08:53PM (#3588270)
>Sigh. I’m quite disillusioned about HN, actually. Not that it should surprise me, but damn. People here say the exact same things as on Reddit. If you squint a bit the reactions are the same. That doesn’t make me happy.

Then perhaps you need to realize that some of the things people are saying have some merit and you're looking at them wrong. I realize ad populum isn't a valid form of logic, but when the great majority of people are telling you you're wrong, it could never hurt to re-examine your position.

Re:Reddit takes a new direction by sophacles on Monday February 13, 2012 @10:39PM (#3588514)
Since you are unhappy here, do us all a favor and just stop coming to the site. The same posts are linked and discussed many other places on the web, where you can have discussion with people who either agree with you, or don't mind you overreacting to disagreements.
Re:Reddit takes a new direction by lwat on Monday February 13, 2012 @07:41PM (#3588061)
> People here say the exact same things as on Reddit.

Perhaps it's because they are correct and you are in fact in the wrong here?