Re:ACM Software System Award Given to seL4 Microkernel
by bee_rider on Saturday May 06, 2023 @02:17PM
(#35843898)
Is there a seL4 implementation targeted at, like, dinking around on some desktop, or is this stuff mostly interesting to embedded-ish folks?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:ACM Software System Award Given to seL4 Microkernel
by bjoli on Saturday May 06, 2023 @02:45PM
(#35844166)
Maybe an ARM desktop once multi core is implemented and verified. Verifying the whole thing for x86 seems scary. It is a kind of undertaking that gives normal people a glimpse of how ADHD is. It is a huge task and I would not know how to structure it, where to start and how to predict and plan all the intermediate steps.
Re:ACM Software System Award Given to seL4 Microkernel
by snvzz on Saturday May 06, 2023 @07:27PM
(#35846332)
>Maybe an ARM desktop once multi core is implemented and verified.
The verification story is currently stronger with RISC-V.
Considering close cooperation between seL4 and RISC-V projects, ARM aka the legacy architecture is unlikely to be a priority anytime soon.
Re:ACM Software System Award Given to seL4 Microkernel
by hedora on Saturday May 06, 2023 @09:43PM
(#35847078)
The only thing that works is modularity.
Write down all the modules, then write down their dependencies on each other. Make sure the dependency graph is as close to a line as possible. This is called “layering” in software engineering.
Now, figure out how to prove each layer correct.
Re:ACM Software System Award Given to seL4 Microkernel
by bjoli on Monday May 08, 2023 @01:03AM
(#35858299)
Of course. But that approach was complex enough for risc-v with is a much much simpler architecture
Re:ACM Software System Award Given to seL4 Microkernel
by ratmice on Saturday May 06, 2023 @03:23PM
(#35844544)
The only thing I know of that provides a desktop is genode, which can run on top of seL4 (but also quite a few other kernels). Given that it'll be more like dinking around with genode than seL4 proper, exactly because of this multi kernel abstraction layer...