What VCS would you use if it was all up to you?
Almost 100% of game devs use Perforce. Git is a non-option.
BigTech all use highly custom source control systems. They have some nice properties.
My stance isn’t that we should use something other than Git per se. It’s that Git is a local maxima, and it kinda sucks. And I think the industry would be healthier if people agreed Git sucks.
Features I care about:
* Terabyte scale sparse checkouts * Ten terabyte scale full checkout * Petabyte scale history * Lossless history. * Automatic cloud/remote backups of every commit * Trivial for low-tech people to use (Perforce achieves this) * Cross-branch file locking for non-mergeable assets
Things I don’t care about:
* Distributed. Defacto centralized with forking is all I need. * Rewriting history. Linux needs it, I don’t.
There are of course lots of things I do like about Git. It’d be good if Git and Perforce had some competition. There’s a market opportunity for it imho.
I think the plumbing is probably in-between poor and bad for most projects. It’s maybe great for Linux. However almost all projects are effectively centralized so the D in DVCS is a waste. (Offline/local support and fully distributed are different). I think source control should make it impossible for 99% of users to shoot themselves in the foot. And Git is still terrible at large binary assets, even with Git-LFS.
I use Git + GitHub for my personal projects. It’s mediocre but tolerable. Git is insufficient and not used for every professional project I have ever worked on. YMMV.