Re:GPT-4 Can’t Replace Striking TV Writers, but Studios Are ...
by adhesive_wombat on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @05:53PM
(#35808288)
There's definitely a tension in my mind between the idea that prompts, which on their own could attract some level of copyright[1], do not produce copyrightable elements in the output and the plaintiffs' claims in the copyright lawsuits against LLM companies that training inputs do.
I'm not sure which side I even agree with more, let alone which side has the stronger legal case (and the balance point will certainly be different in different jurisdictions).
[1]: tweets are copyrightable (subject to the usual creative input, originally, etc requirements) and a detailed AI prompt can certainly be as involved as a tweet.
Re:GPT-4 Can’t Replace Striking TV Writers, but Studios Are ...
by dllthomas on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @06:08PM
(#35808459)
I don't have a well thought through opinion on what the resolution should be, but it seems hugely inconsistent that pointing my camera at whatever in my environment, with little thought or care or creativity, produces something copyright covers while carefully picking a prompt to get the sort of image I want out of a different sort of machine does not.
The Copyright Office opinion on that only states that is the case when there is no human involvement beyond prompting, and in any case, with the Supreme Court likely to strike down Chevron deference in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, that opinion may quite soon have very little weight.