Re:The Socratic Method: Teaching by Asking Instead of by Tel...
by jfarmer on Saturday February 11, 2012 @12:14PM
(#3579601)
It is. It's just like Meno's slave.
Re:The Socratic Method: Teaching by Asking Instead of by Tel...
by jmilloy on Saturday February 11, 2012 @09:52PM
(#3580958)
There are lots of question and answer situations -- not all of them are the Socratic Method. I prefer a narrow definition: the Method was largely "to elicit admissions, as from an opponent, tending to establish a proposition" [1] and, esp. regarding education, pertains more to the discovery of philosophic Truths. In Meno's slave, the point isn't to teach someone geometry but to prove that teaching is possible, i.e. that any uneducated person could follow logical arguments and learn; the philosophic truth at hand is learning. What is the philosophic truth at hand in this case?
Of course, eliciting information from students, regardless of what you call it, is a well known and essential aspect of any good lesson plan. It is a real challenge to ask the right questions and stick with it when students aren't making the discoveries you want, and it's tremendously rewarding when it works. But it's not the whole story, and I think it's tempting to get excited when it works and lose sight of the longterm goals for you students. For many topics, it must be followed at some point with practice, and a LOT of it. It can leave some students totally behind. In fact, it's actually still quite teacher-centric, and should be used in short segments and (when possible) replaced by student-centric activities.