News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by tjr on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:00PM (#35790677)
Companies banning the use of ChatGPT level tools going forward will find the rules either flouted, subverted or the employees going elsewhere.

Why? Companies typically have many rules that they expect employees to follow. Why would employees disregard these particular rules, or even quit because of them?

Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by hxugufjfjf on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:26PM (#35791101)
Because it quickly became a tool that was so useful that I feel I am doing my job better with than without now that it’s available. Similiar to how I would disregard rules and/or quit if I was not allowed to use my operating system of choice at work or was denied the use of a specific tool integral to doing my job (well).
Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by tjr on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:30PM (#35791172)
Ah, so you are not disregarding this particular rule, but you disregard all rules that you feel impede you. That answers my question, thank you -- this has nothing in particular to do with GPT tools.
Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by hxugufjfjf on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:38PM (#35791306)
No. I follow many rules, even if I like them or not. I picked one simple example of a rule I would consider a dealbreaker for my employment to illustrate how many people have already started using ChatGPT so heavily in their workflows that they would consider it detrimental if their employer took it away from them. But yes, it might not really have anything to do with GPT specifically besides it apparently being a very useful tool for a lot of employees, given that some would at least claim to quit their jobs over being prevented from using it.
Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by tjr on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:46PM (#35791447)
Thank you again. I did not mean to claim that you disregard literally all rules, and I apologize for coming across that way.

I find your explanation sound and reasonable. There are many rules that, even if not necessarily liked, are not sufficient grounds to do anything about. But sometimes rules may impede your workflow so much that you find it preferable to either quietly work around the rule, or even to quit.

Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by hxugufjfjf on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:58PM (#35791634)
I appreciate your apology as it sort of came across that way.

I'll give you a real-life anecdotal example to expand a little on my point. My buddy is a front-end developer for a company which produce pretty basic "stuff" (sorry, I don't know anything about front-end) according to him. He says that he's gotten lazy and unmotivated to do anything about it. This leaves him unchallenged and he doesn't really like his job. Once GPT arrived, he's been able to (according to himself) reduce 70 % of the boring boiler-plate code type work he has been doing for years, by making GPT write it for him, and him just verifying it works. This has ultimately allowed him not only to focus on taking on more interesting projects where he can challenge himself, but also spending a lot of the time he previously spent writing "bullshit boiler-plate code" in learning new and more challenging front-end things.

I can easily imagine people in other jobs, in IT or perhaps in other fields already using GPT to reduce the boring parts of their jobs. I can genuinly not recall having heard anyone say a new IDE or any other tool since the arrival of the computer itself reduce their "boring work" load this signifcantly. So I think at this point it is reasonable to assume that access to GPT will become considered as commonplace as having access to a computer or email (given you work in a field where those are considered basic/primary tools of course), and that employers will have to adapt. If not, people will disregard rules / go "shadow IT" or even consider quitting.

Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by tjr on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:05PM (#35791748)
A fascinating example story! I think that does make it all make more sense why one would quit over not being able to use ChatGPT.
Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by bavila on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:56PM (#35792443)
Perhaps the fact that I work exclusively on the front-end is why I also derive tremendous value from GPT-4, and I have been perplexed by others saying they find no value in GPT-4 for coding. There is so much boilerplate BS that GPT-4 just nails down and lets me move on to bigger things.

Just yesterday, I needed to mock up a quick prototype for a new feature we're developing. I just paste in my existing React component (and it's all front-end code with no sensitive/proprietary information), tell GPT-4 what I want it to do, and it does it.

Is it perfect? No. Does it sometimes get things wrong? Yes. But it's still easier and faster to help guide GPT-4 and tweak its final output than to have done it all myself.

I'll never go back. Never.

Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by blibble on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @08:03PM (#35795979)
boilerplate is a sign of shitty abstractions and libraries

and generating boilerplate is the road to madness

Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by bavila on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:28PM (#35797005)
What can I say? It's a dirty job. :)
Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by ipaddr on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @09:37PM (#35796636)
If your job has a lot of boilerplate this is helpful. If your job is finding/solving complex system wide bugs this doesn't help as much.
Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @12:55AM (#35798168)
Don’t you have your own templates?
Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by meghan_rain on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:39PM (#35791321)
Arrogant software devs thinking this labour shortage of code monkeys will continue in perpetuity
Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by sangnoir on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:00PM (#35791664)
What labor shortage? It's an employer's market right now, with a glut of high-quality candidates looking for jobs.
Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by redmaverick on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:12PM (#35790868)
simple reason. I can refactor the codebase in a dozen different ways in a matter of seconds and choose the best one to work on. I can a summon a large volume of unit tests, descriptive logging statements etc. I can also just dump the logs and it will 9/10 times tell you right away what the issue is and how you can resolve it.

i.e basically you can do a lot of work in just a matter of hours. Once you taste the productivity increase by integrating AI into your workflow you will miss it if it is taken out.

not mention you can build all the handy little tools in a matter of seconds that will make your daily life way easier.

Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by tjr on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:28PM (#35791146)
Employees have been prevented (by rule) from doing things that would make them more productive for a long time. For a trivial example, programmers who are proficient in Emacs not being allowed to install and use Emacs.

I still fail to see why employees will now choose to disregard this particular rule, and either disobey or quit.

Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by EFreethought on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @07:03PM (#35795365)
Honestly, "no Emacs" is one rule that would make me quit.
Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by ParetoOptimal on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:50AM (#35802377)
So would I. Funnily enough I thought it might happen at a job in the past so I've thought through the "would you quit if work banned Emacs" question quite a bit.
Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by ParetoOptimal on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:52AM (#35802412)
> For a trivial example, programmers who are proficient in Emacs not being allowed to install and use Emacs.

I'm not sure how you mean trivial here, but not being able to use emacs isn't a trivial matter to emacs users :)

> I still fail to see why employees will now choose to disregard this particular rule, and either disobey or quit.

I fail to see why employees follow rules that make no sense rather than disobeying or quitting.

Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by unethical_ban on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:02PM (#35791697)
Shadow IT.

Companies can have reasonable cause to block things, or require processes for installing software, etc., but when those burdens become too much time or effort employees will find a way around it.

Almost a decade ago, the company I worked for didn't have good wiki software OR a good request system. My team had a linux server for the purpose of some primitive monitoring and automation of our systems. Apache was already installed...

Within a few weeks we operationalized a new dokuwiki installation, and not long after that we built an internal request system based on Bottle.py (since it didn't require any installation, only a single file).

Seeing that GPT-4 is so incredibly useful to the people I've heard talk about it, there will be employees trying to use it to increase their code quality, communications, planning, etc.

My current employer put out guidance specifically stating not to put any proprietary code into it, no matter how small, nor any confidential information of any kind (don't format your internal earnings email with it, for example).

That seems reasonable, and recognizes how hard it will be for employees to go zero-tolerance, especially if they don't have total network control over work endpoints.

Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by jupp0r on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @09:01PM (#35796393)
Just imagine companies would not allow people to use internet search engines for their daily work.
Re:Samsung bans use of A.I. like ChatGPT for employees after... by loeg on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:05PM (#35796851)
Sure, but those are actually useful.