Re:I Was Laid Off in Retaliation for Anti-Discrimination Whi...
by tptacek on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:58AM
(#35789584)
It read to me like he was just commenting on your frustration that the law and all our norms don't instantaneously proscribe all possible forms of discrimination, that there isn't a plausible generalizable principle of "just don't discriminate", even if it's easy to anticipate that we shouldn't allow discrimination against e.g. trans people.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:I Was Laid Off in Retaliation for Anti-Discrimination Whi...
by ajross on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:09PM
(#35789777)
> there isn't a plausible generalizable principle of "just don't discriminate"
You'd at least agree that there ought to be an extremely high bar for "do not hire" exclusions like this, no?
It seems like both of you are interpreting what I wrote above in a senselessly absolutist way, which seems deeply uncharitable. I'm all for debating moral ethics in the abstract. I'm just a little horrified to see two major thought leaders on this site engaging in this particular direction.
Re:I Was Laid Off in Retaliation for Anti-Discrimination Whi...
by tptacek on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:15PM
(#35789872)
Absolutely. I assume he would too. I don't have an opinion about what you wrote, but I make a habit of reading all of Berlin's comments, and it seemed like you two were just communicating at cross purposes. I'm not judging or anything.