Re:The Computer Scientist Peering Inside AI’s Black Boxes
by low_tech_love on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @06:23AM
(#35785487)
Yes, I totally agree, and thanks for the Karpathy link, it’s really good. And yes I don’t know at which level is the sweet spot. But the fact that it’s software 2.0 means we need debugging 2.0 too.
Suppose you have the spinning color wheel on your MacBook. You give it to a computer scientist who says that the program is in an infinite loop, and the wheel will never stop spinning. Then you give the computer to a superhuman physicist who studies all of the components including the state of the transistors and internal components and concludes that the wheel will spin for 9 years before the screen gives out. [1]
The point is that both are correct, but we’d really prefer the first explanation, since it gives insight into what the program is doing.
The problem is that neural networks aren’t like programs. They don’t have reducible internal components unless you reduce down to the weights of the network itself. [2]
[1] https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=k0CQ_D7dwA0
[2] https://karpathy.medium.com/software-2-0-a64152b37c35