In a world where individuals or very small groups of people are increasingly gaining the power to do potentially catastrophic damage using increasingly powerful technology, what are the actual alternatives we could see being presented ? Trust?
How do you actually see society functioning going forwards without at least some oversight ?
Don't get me wrong, I don't want society to go this way, but I'm starting to see fewer and fewer options presented to Governments.
In my opinion, the US Government know this, they have smart advisors. This is why they always seem to be trying to attain more and more surveillance capabilities while trying not to be stealthy about it.
I wouldn't pretend I know the answer, but I think we have to admit the world has changed quite a bit recently.
What happens when the state intelligence apparatus has the ability to perfectly surveil the population? Look no further than what the Stasi accomplished - it becomes trivially easy to discredit political opposition, journalists, business leaders, or any other person or group standing in the way of the powerful.
People split hairs about this kind of oversight, or that kind of oversight, but when the powerful are overseeing their own surveillance apparatus - using secret courts, secret warrants, and all manner of other methods for hiding the true scope of the surveillance - I do not believe it can be contained.
It is basically only ok if you can guarantee it’s users always use it in good faith which is virtually impossible.
So, for the first five minutes.
“It is better, so the Fourth Amendment teaches, that the guilty sometimes go free than the citizens be subject to easy arrest.” William Douglas, Associate Justice of the Supreme Court. The argument to give up your rights is always initially used to target the worst of the worst. Its always terrorists, spies, child murderers, etc. Of course we shouldn't be slowed down by due process when it is for this child murderer. Yet it is then used against those least likely to be able to defend themselves for easy wins. Russian spies first, then its minor crimes committed by immigrants.
Granted, the website is dedicated to mass surveillance in the IT. But then think, generally speaking, is the mass surveillance on some reasonable level really so bad? It's helping identifying Russian soldiers who are committing war crimes and atrocities in Ukraine. It helps preserve the free and democratic society rather than creates a road to dystopia. Of course, I'm speaking of some reasonable levels, not of something like real-time client device scanning. It doesn't make any sense and it would simply not work.