Re:Rate The Landlord: Anonymously share information with ten...
by cdmckay on Sunday April 30, 2023 @09:27AM
(#35762330)
In Barcelona (and I think all of Spain), your 1-month deposit is kept by the state and is automatically returned to you unless the landlord can prove that you did something that entitles them to it.
Re:Rate The Landlord: Anonymously share information with ten...
by tough on Sunday April 30, 2023 @09:33AM
(#35762391)
The landlord is supposedly legally enforced to put the money in the chamber of commerce, but ALAS not all of them will (even if it's illegal) and many will also try to scam you out of your deposit if they see they can get away with it.
Re:Rate The Landlord: Anonymously share information with ten...
by nibbleshifter on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:41AM
(#35762973)
Its the same in the UK. But many landlords aren't compliant with this, and enforcement varies
Re:Rate The Landlord: Anonymously share information with ten...
by jackcosgrove on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:15AM
(#35762747)
In Chicago landlords have to send you an annual check paying out the interest, which during the low interest rate years amounted to 10-30¢ a year. The postage stamp cost more.
In response landlords started to require non-refundable move-in fees in lieu of a security deposit. These can range between about 40-60% of a month's rent.
Re:Rate The Landlord: Anonymously share information with ten...
by tyoma on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:41AM
(#35762974)
This is considerably more fair than charging some tenants 100% of a months rent (if they don’t know their rights) and others 0% (if they do). Also the fact the money is gone is stated upfront and agreed to by both parties.
Re:Rate The Landlord: Anonymously share information with ten...
by BeFlatXIII on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:39AM
(#35763581)
More fair but more deadweight loss for everyone involved.
Re:Rate The Landlord: Anonymously share information with ten...
by mochomocha on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:26AM
(#35762857)
> Refusing to return security deposits is absolutely a low income landlord strategy.
Oh I've had this happen to me from a "high income landlord" in San Francisco. Penny pincher lady living in a wealthy neighborhood, repairing herself the leaky roof of the SF building she owns with duct tape. Tried to keep my deposit until, like the comment you're replying to, I threatened to bring her to small claims court. I had the deposit in my mailbox the next day.
Re:Rate The Landlord: Anonymously share information with ten...
by escapedmoose on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:12PM
(#35766673)
I’ve never rented in a low-income area, but I’ve still had this problem with every single landlord I’ve had. Never did have the pleasure of meeting the “honest landlord” though I have always been, by all accounts, a model tenant.
It was so endemic in Chicago that it was standard practice to withhold last month’s rent and send the landlord a letter saying to take the security deposit and send you a bill for any repairs.
This is both against the lease and financially equivalent to what an honest landlord would do, except the burden to get paid is now on the landlord.
If they have kept your security deposit in a separate, interest bearing account as the law requires[0] there should be no problem in the transaction.
0. Hahahahaha there was exactly one landlord I had who actually did this (not in Chicago) and returned my full security deposit with interest.