Re:FDIC set to take First Republic Bank into receivership
by pclmulqdq on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:58AM
(#35753502)
I'm pretty sure there literally isn't enough money held by rich people to have the effect that you want.
The top 1% own about 25% of assets in the US, and of that the vast majority are likely illiquid and non-cash. If you assume that the top 1% hypothetically hold 10% of the cash, then draining their cash accounts to 0 and burning it would be equivalent (not counting money velocity) to everyone else taking a 10% haircut. If you attempt to account for the velocity of money, that would likely only be a small single-digit percentage. The CPI is higher than that, and many lower- and middle-class families are seeing a much bigger loss in purchasing power thanks to increases in the prices of food, fuel, and housing.
Moreover, the last 2 years have been an experiment in exactly what you are proposing - using monetary policy to control inflation while using fiscal policy to attempt to prevent it from hitting most people. It has not worked, and it will not work in the future. In fact, the policy has had the opposite effect that you probably want: real wealth is increasingly concentrated in the hands of the wealthy, and inflation is largely concentrated in products purchased by the poor.
The top 1% own about 25% of assets in the US, and of that the vast majority are likely illiquid and non-cash. If you assume that the top 1% hypothetically hold 10% of the cash, then draining their cash accounts to 0 and burning it would be equivalent (not counting money velocity) to everyone else taking a 10% haircut. If you attempt to account for the velocity of money, that would likely only be a small single-digit percentage. The CPI is higher than that, and many lower- and middle-class families are seeing a much bigger loss in purchasing power thanks to increases in the prices of food, fuel, and housing.
Moreover, the last 2 years have been an experiment in exactly what you are proposing - using monetary policy to control inflation while using fiscal policy to attempt to prevent it from hitting most people. It has not worked, and it will not work in the future. In fact, the policy has had the opposite effect that you probably want: real wealth is increasingly concentrated in the hands of the wealthy, and inflation is largely concentrated in products purchased by the poor.