I'd say well over 85% of the time, I "know" the bulk deal is the better one for me - I might do the 'cheaper' option once (in this case, the $1.90 for the first month), and then convert to the 'bulk' deal as soon as I know I like it
...but personal experience has shown that if I'm going to like something for a month, I'm going to like it a lot longer :)
If it's like 99% other products that offer bulk deals, I don't know such a long time ahead whether I'll end up using it that much. The expectation of savings by taking the "worse" short-term deal is higher than taking the supposed advantageous lifetime/bulk deal in my case.