News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I have a bad feeling about this by pbhjpbhj on Thursday February 09, 2012 @11:00PM (#3574445)
Copyright is monopoly protection granted on your works by the demos on the assumption of that work becoming freely available to the public domain in a reasonable time.

If your work is not going to enter the public domain then there's no contract - the state then is enforcing a monopoly against the interests of the people.

Disney can make a profit of 100s of millions on a movie within a few years. They don't need anything like as much as 20 years.

They will of course retain their trademarks, and I think this is only right in a realistic IP environment.

>relaxed copyright laws //

Relaxation general means less strict or less firmly applied. This suggests an assumption that the state should grant a monopoly - there should be no such assumption but instead the application of a strict limited time contract in accordance with the original purposes of the law.

Re:I have a bad feeling about this by Wilduck on Friday February 10, 2012 @10:48AM (#3576209)
> This suggests an assumption that the state should grant a monopoly.

That wasn't my intention. I wanted to emphasize that it already has. I think the state should work to ensure the creation of public goods and I think that they should relax copyright laws.

I'd love to read a rigorous analysis of this idea:

> Disney can make a profit of 100s of millions on a movie within a few years. They don't need anything like as much as 20 years. > They will of course retain their trademarks, and I think this is only right in a realistic IP environment.