Re:Open Access Bill for (nearly) all US publicly-funded rese...
by elehack on Thursday February 09, 2012 @02:28PM
(#3572627)
I really like seeing this bill come up - the opposite of the Research Works Act, and a bill that will greatly improve access to research in the U.S.
I am concerned, however, that it uses “peer reviewed journals” as the standard for mandating publication. Computer science does most of its ongoing publication in conferences, not journals; also, specifically naming “journals” seems to me to invite name games, unless journal is defined sufficiently broadly in the bill's text.
I would prefer to see the requirements kick in when research is published in any peer-reviewed publication.
But still, this bill is a great step forward, and things like this are details that can hopefully be worked out.
Re:Open Access Bill for (nearly) all US publicly-funded rese...
by hpiwowar on Saturday February 11, 2012 @05:06PM
(#3580316)
Worth noting that this bill allows but does not require access for text mining. For example, papers in PubMed Central can not be systematically downloaded (PMC is the result of a previous rule within the NIH).
According to Peter Suber, "If it's passed, agencies will have a year to adopt their own policies, and we can then press them to require libre."
I am concerned, however, that it uses “peer reviewed journals” as the standard for mandating publication. Computer science does most of its ongoing publication in conferences, not journals; also, specifically naming “journals” seems to me to invite name games, unless journal is defined sufficiently broadly in the bill's text.
I would prefer to see the requirements kick in when research is published in any peer-reviewed publication.
But still, this bill is a great step forward, and things like this are details that can hopefully be worked out.
According to Peter Suber, "If it's passed, agencies will have a year to adopt their own policies, and we can then press them to require libre."
https://plus.google.com/116956861224568841998/posts/DPcA4f1q...
Many more details are available here: http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/hoap/Notes_on_the_Federal_Resea...