News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is OAuth still hard in 2023? by klabb3 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @06:43PM (#35720964)
For service accounts, email is clearly not the right choice. I don’t have experience with enterprise auth, are Kerberos etc not using company email for human identity?

> this proposed system requires that every app has ability to send emails, which honestly is less simple than it sounds

For humans and especially end-users of consumer services, my observation is that the elaborate auth dances are using email ownership as last resort anyway, ie for account recovery and/or a trusted 3p that has verified the email. So the thought is simply to make that flow more convenient. Perhaps this is misguided.

Re:Why is OAuth still hard in 2023? by p_l on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @07:58PM (#35721544)
In case of OAuth2/OIDC, if I do not use external providers (like Google etc.), I can still deploy one of the many OAuth2/OIDC providers myself and centralise handling of user database this way.

This also means I have one place to support sending last resort emails

As for enterprise auth, a lot of places in fact do not use emails for identity. Sometimes there's more than one login id mapping to one identity (noticeable case - Kerberos/LDAP as done by Active Directory, where your login can come in email-style form and pre-AD form, and the email-style one doesn't have to correspond to an email)