News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by jjoonathan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:52AM (#35714576)
The problems with this policy are obvious, but it brings benefits too: we are allowed to develop new technology. If self driving has to be rigorously proven before it can be tested, the chicken-egg problem simply resolves itself into "the tech won't be developed here." Is that really what HN wants?
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by kibwen on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:04AM (#35714806)
As a pedestrian and cyclist, what I want is to not become a statistic in a crash report. We can develop new things and test them under controlled conditions without having to put everyone outside the car at risk.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by jjoonathan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:14AM (#35714991)
AI is easily our best bet against the true menace, which is distracted drivers.

No, "controlled conditions" don't do a very good job of training or proving an AI. Supervised cars on actual roads is the way it has to be.

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by acdha on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:46AM (#35715614)
Speed limiters and automatic braking get most of the benefits without any need for hard AI problems. What AI promises is a way for governments not to have to take the heat for holding drivers accountable, but hundreds of thousands of people are being killed waiting for it to materialize.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by piva00 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:53AM (#35725155)
The best bet against the true menace is to deploy public policies that reduces the true menace: the number of cars/drivers on the streets.

That's the most sound policy, provide the public with alternative means of transportation that are convenient and more environment-friendly, leave room on the streets for the ones that actually require a car for their transportation. If you leave in the middle of bumfuck nowhere and can't be served by public transportation, great, you probably need a car. If you drive your car in cities for trips of 5-10km because it's convenient then we, as a society, should find ways to disincentivise this usage.