I'm appalled the NTSB hasn't reigned in Tesla. I'm cynical enough to start wondering what officials they've "bought off."
1) Tesla hasn't demonstrated that future hypothetical, so it's a speculative argument at best.
2) It's still unethical if they could have achieved that more safely by following industry norms and best practices, which they consistently fail to implement. Tesla could hire safety drivers for testing before public releases, but they don't. They could implement more redundancy to mitigate SPOF, but they don't. They could file the same regulatory paperwork others do (insufficient as that is), but they don't do that either. They don't even use industry standard terminology and safety concepts like ODDs.
But technically, Tesla is “fully self driving” in the sense that it can autonomously navigate, steer, etc. That doesn’t mean it won’t crash. It’s also still in Beta.
In the long run, I think FSD will become better than the majority of human drivers. Seemingly, the only way these remaining edge cases can be solved is by collecting more training data from real world driving scenarios. So the NTSB is faced with the difficult decision of allowing this Beta version to crash and even cause fatalities in the short run, betting on the prediction it will drastically improve road safety in the long run. It’s a complicated dilemma, in my opinion.
You fell for a very common misuse of statistics there. It may become better than the average human driver, but the sample for that average includes the 5-10% of drivers who cause almost all accidents. Like for other things where power laws apply using averages (or medians) on that data essentially removes any information.
FSD likely requires GAI.
The GAI requirement is an interesting theory but why? I find it dubious because, at least personally, driving seems to occur semi automatically in my motor cortex. When a car pulls out in front of me I’m not using my frontal cortex to slam on the brakes. It feels involuntary.
From a few anecdotal experiences in this thread, you would be able to tell subconsciously that that Burger King sign is not a stop sign, not even for a brief second, that floating plastic bag is not an object that one has to avoid collision with and there are just millions of edge cases humans properly handle.
Of course I might be wrong and it might not require GAI, but there is still no human construction that can even close on a human brain.
Isn’t it more realistic that FSD is one of those classic engineering problems where the last 10% takes 90% of the effort?
Also, the “move fast and break things” is symptomatic of the broader tech industry. Despite being glorified for decades, it’s become a toxic mentality that’s hurt us with social media, and is now exponentially more pronounced with AI. Sure, maybe Elon should be “made an example of”, but collectively we need to sober up and realize this is a systematic issue in tech rather than scapegoating one eccentric billionaire.