News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by jjoonathan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:22AM (#35714101)
Yes, and we have to mind the denominator too. Waymo just announced 1 million self driving miles, Tesla just announced 150 million self driving miles.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by ra7 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:38AM (#35714319)
Waymo self driving is not at all the same as Tesla’s. One is fully driverless and the other requires driver monitoring.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by jjoonathan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:50AM (#35714532)
Yes, but Tesla does have a driver monitoring, so that's the relevant safety number.

Nobody, even Tesla, is currently arguing that Tesla FSD is ready for driverless.

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by tasty_freeze on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:59AM (#35714702)
You just pointed out that the two driving assists are apples and oranges ... yet it was you who compared Waymo's driverless car total mileage vs Tesla's FSD.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by jjoonathan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:21AM (#35715123)
We are talking about safety and risk, not dick measuring the tech stack. Tesla has 150x the miles, which means that for the same risk level they should see 150x the problems. Maybe divide that by 3 to account for highway vs around town. I don't see 50x the number of "Tesla killed my dog" stories as "Waymo killed my dog" stories, so Tesla probably isn't taking egregious risks. What's your heuristic?
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by simondotau on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:14PM (#35722513)
This is correct but misleading. Waymo and Tesla are pursuing strategies so different that attempting to compare them is futile.

It's true that within the small geofences in which Waymo operates, their cars are dramatically less likely to come unstuck than a Tesla running FSD beta. On the other hand FSD beta drives on pretty much any public road and not a curated set of pre-driven, pre-mapped, pre-validated streets. Yes there are many geographies where it struggles; there's a cottage industry of people obsessively showing these on YouTube. There are also some areas of the country where FSD beta is utterly rock solid and people routinely drive substantial distances with zero interventions.

It's also not entirely accurate to describe Waymo cars as "fully driverless" as they have a team of human employees remotely monitoring the fleet and can remotely operate any vehicle.

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by ra7 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:23PM (#35722575)
> It's also not entirely accurate to describe Waymo cars as "fully driverless" as they have a team of human employees remotely monitoring the fleet and can remotely operate any vehicle.

This is absolutely not true. Waymo remote agents cannot operate a vehicle. All they can do is answer questions from the vehicle or plot a path to go around if it gets stuck. They cannot make any safety critical interventions. Waymo has talked about this many times.

It’s fully driverless because the vehicle is responsible for attaining minimal risk condition all on its own. This is how other L4 companies like Cruise works too.

Zoox has a good explanation on how their teleguidance works: https://youtube.com/watch?v=NKQHuutVx78

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by simondotau on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:37AM (#35725542)
“Plot a path to go” is literally what it means to control the vehicle remotely.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by ra7 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:37AM (#35727109)
Nope, that’s misleading. Still no “control” over the vehicle because the vehicle is executing the move. It’s assisting the vehicle. They don’t have the ability to joystick the car.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by simondotau on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:31AM (#35728705)
Your point is that the Waymo operator isn't really in control because the vehicle can ignore instructions; the on-board computer won't allow the remote operator's instructions to result in a collision. If I attempt to drive my own car into a brick wall, the on-board computer will defy my instructions as best it can too. By your definition, I'm not in control of my car just like Waymo operators aren't.

Fact is, a Waymo operator can take enough control of the vehicle to be considered in control of it. It doesn't matter if control comes in the form of a steering wheel or a joystick or drawing vectors on a map. Control is control, whether it's direct, indirect, or funnelled through a governor. Waymo operators can intervene and direct the car as needed.

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by ra7 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:40AM (#35728855)
> If I attempt to drive my own car into a brick wall, the on-board computer will defy my instructions as best it can too. By your definition, I'm not in control of my car just like Waymo operators aren't.

Terrible analogy. You are sitting in the driver's seat with your hands on the wheel. If your car is about to hit someone, you can prevent it because you are the driver. This is what FSD is — ultimately driver is in control. No such luxury for Waymo/Cruise as their remote operators cannot do any safety critical interventions like preventing crashes.

All they can do is non-safety critical interventions by way of passing indirect commands. A Waymo is in control of itself at all times and is fully responsible for its own safety. You can play with words like "control" all you want, but this is the definition of SAE Level 4 autonomy.

If anything, calling FSD "autonomous" is highly misleading because drivers are preventing mistakes and thereby hiding its real safety outcome.

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by simondotau on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:46PM (#35736650)
> Terrible analogy.

I agree, it's a terrible analogy if I was attempting to make the argument you thought I was trying to make, per your explanation for why it's a terrible analogy.

My point is that it's invalid to say that Waymo operators don't have "control" of the vehicle because it can refuse to perform some tasks. Because my car can refuse to perform some tasks too.

The deeper point is that the difference between "in control" and "not in control" isn't binary. It's all points along a continuum. If a Waymo operator controls a vehicle remotely, it's not the same level of control as a human holding the steering wheel. But it's still control in the larger sense. If the operator wants the car to stop, it will stop. Period. If they want the car to perform some action that isn't stupid or dangerous (such as colliding with a pedestrian) it will perform that action.

> If anything, calling FSD "autonomous" is highly misleading

I agree. Which is why I didn't. In most situations FSD beta can handle the "full" task of driving. By "full", they mean it's not intended to be limited to a strict subset of task, e.g. only on highways. It can "fully self drive" the car competently at least ~99.9% of the time, as evidenced by the fact that it can routinely drive most roads reliably. Drives shown on YouTube are mostly owners intentionally looking for roads which flummox it, as that's how they show improvements as software updates are released.

The challenges which preclude FSD from being a system capable of autonomy — the 0.1% of remaining error — isn't errors in spatial awareness or control surface failure. It's stuff like path planning and road sign interpretation, neither of which involve sensors that Tesla vehicles lack.

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by tsimionescu on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:53AM (#35714600)
Tesla has 0 self-driving miles, since a driver is always there and is fully responsible for any mistake that happens.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by lern_too_spel on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:01PM (#35715881)
Waymo had 20 million self driving miles on public roads in 2021. Earlier this year, Waymo announced 1 million self driving miles on public roads with nobody in the driver's seat. Tesla has 0 such miles.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by jjoonathan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:39PM (#35716478)
Thanks for clarifying! So Tesla has 7x the miles and so if their test program is riskier we should expect to see >7x the number of accidents.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by lern_too_spel on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @04:11PM (#35719319)
We see far more than 7x at fault accidents. As far as I know, Waymo has had none. Tesla has had so many that it had to post a recall notice.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by bradtemp on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:18AM (#35723246)
No because when Tesla's system has a problem, as my car does a few times each trip, I grab the wheel. And waymo also has cars with safety drivers but also has run a million miles without one. Run Tesla FSD with no intervention for a million miles and it would have thousands of accidents. Thousands, where it was at fault. Waymo had 2 or 3 minor parking lot style no damage contacts in their million. Not thousands
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by kaba0 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:58PM (#35716786)
On motorways mostly, where the problem is almost trivial. If you add to it that it is much easier to accumulate miles there, Waymo’s number is much more impressive.

It’s a bit like stress testing two frameworks, one tested only for a day, but at the frontpage of HN, while the other was up for a months, with barely any clicks.