My unpleasant encounter with canceling the WSJ alone has made me quite hesitant about subscribing to most printed media. At that time, even though I was a subscriber in Europe, I needed to call in to their US office, wait in long queues, and hear out their customer support offers before I could cancel. This was in the 2000s when long-distance international calls were notably expensive. In another instance, I gifted someone a one-year subscription to a different magazine, and it proved challenging to cancel without involving the recipient, even though I was the one being charged. The most frustrating episode involved a third magazine: I subscribed for a fixed, pre-paid one-year term, but continued to receive magazines, invoices, and past-due letters after for an "unpaid" subscription, which felt like a credit rating extortion.
As a result, no periodical will convince me to subscribe in the future. It's just not worth the stress. I don't understand what the magazines are doing employing these tactics. Declining paid subscriber numbers will force them into the clickbait, SEO spam, and ad-driven media cycle online from which it's very difficult to recover and regain trust. The online landscape is a graveyard of many previously trusted paid publications that were forced to move online to survive. I hate this trend, and yet, I don't think it's reasonable for me to put myself in a position where I'd have to deal with obstacles in cancellations and extortion again.
I wonder if as the subscription landscape gets more “toxic”, it’s a net negative for the whole industry. Even above-board offerings will get ignored by would-be customers that no longer trust.