Education is not my field but there are ways to identify causal effects outside of experiments.
So: you are wrong when you say “the only way to do this is…”
For example:
- Regression discontinuity (find a college that accepts people who score >=X on a test, then compare people who scored X vs people who scored X-epsilon)
- Instrumental variables (find something that would nudge people to go to college, like living close to a college)
- Natural experiments (find an event that 'forced' many people to suddenly sign up, like 'avoiding the Vietnam war draft').
[1] Section 4 of https://sci-hub.se/https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-economics...
University is now a business, and the product is degrees and "college experience", the customers are students. The product has suffered; degrees are no longer rigorous. Teaching faculty have suffered; tenure tracks has disappeared in favor of adjunct part time faculty. Students suffer under mountains of debt. The only winners are the legions of administrators. Some schools have as many as 1 administrator per 1 student. It's absurd.
I am both a graduate school and high school dropout. A motivated individual could replace university with a library and Internet connection. However, proving one's knowledge can be more difficult than acquiring it. A degree makes it easier to communicate and demonstrate skill.
the bigger sample bias is that wealthy people almost universally send their children to college and their children are always going to earn above average wages.
it is pretty obvious that people who graduate college are going to earn more because large numbers of high paying jobs require a college degree, but that is a bad thing.
jobs that require specific skills should have objective skills tests to qualify for the job. requiring a degree for a job should be prohibited by law because it is blatantly discriminatory.
I fail to see how this statistic can be calculated in a scientifically rigorous way.
The only method would be to pick a pool of people, randomly divide the pool in two, and then force half to go to college, while you force the other half not to.
Any other approach suffers from sampling bias - the smart motivated ones find a way to go to college, while the rest stay home and stack shelves at walmart for a lifetime.
And now you're saying that being smart and motivated earns you more... Well no surprise there!