News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google cloud Europe is out by londons_explore on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @09:07AM (#35713072)
> There is a separate issue stopping changes to HTTP load balancers across most of GCP

Is it me, or has Google had issues with pushing changes to load balancers pretty much every few months for the past decade? Even before GCP launched, people here on HN sometimes said an outage was extended because load balancer configs couldn't be changed.

Have they not considered just redesigning their config push mechanism...

Re:Google cloud Europe is out by derefr on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @09:59AM (#35713754)
My impression is that the GCLB config for a given region's LBs is a global multitenant resource (which makes sense; there are only so many network switches serving the DC); where, to avoid that resource being constantly interrupted by config changes, all individual tenant GCLB config changes instead get thrown into a queue, where some scheduled batch process reduces over all config changes in the queue to compute a new global GCLB config state every 7–15 minutes, and pushes that, interrupting the LBs just once per interval.

(A famous speedrunning analogy: you can do everything else to remediate your app problems as fast as you like, but your LB config update arrives at a bus stop, and must wait for the next bus to come. If it just missed the previous bus, it has to wait around longer for the next one.)

It's intriguing to me that AFAIK load-balancer changes in AWS don't suffer from this problem. (Though, on the other hand, CDN changes do.)

Re:Google cloud Europe is out by re-thc on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:05AM (#35713843)
> It's intriguing to me that AFAIK load-balancer changes in AWS don't suffer from this problem. (Though, on the other hand, CDN changes do.)

The architecture is a lot different.

Using google means working with the load balancer in some form. It's all interconnected.

AWS is all separate parts that are stitched together thinly.

E.g. you can have a single global load balancer in Google that handles your whole infrastructure (CDN and WAF are part of LB too). There isn't an AWS equivalent. You would need a global accelerator + ALBs per region and more. WAF is tied to each ALB etc.

Re:Google cloud Europe is out by wkat4242 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:19AM (#35715073)
> AWS is all separate parts that are stitched together thinly.

Yeah I always hate this when I have to work with AWS. All their services feel like they were designed by completely different companies. Every management interface looks and feels different, and there are tons of services that do almost the same thing so it's not clear which would be best to use. It's a maze to me.

Luckily I don't have to work with cloud a lot but I really prefer Azure where everything is in the same console and there isn't a lot of overlap. But cloud guys seem to hate it, not sure why.

Re:Google cloud Europe is out by d0gsg0w00f on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:30PM (#35716331)

    > I really prefer Azure where everything is in the same console and there isn't a lot of overlap. But cloud guys seem to hate it, not sure why.
Because Azure API's are always changing and their SDK support for non-C# is wild west.

Also, everything is a Wizard because MS doesn't want to expose the sausage factory.

Re:Google cloud Europe is out by electroly on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:42AM (#35715537)
AWS separates the anycast LB functionality into a separate service called AWS Global Accelerator. You do get individual anycast IP addresses with that service.
Re:Google cloud Europe is out by derefr on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:52AM (#35715739)
Ah, interesting; it's been a while since I played with AWS, and that service wasn't there back then. I'm guessing that allocating a new AWS Global Accelerator address takes a while?
Re:Google cloud Europe is out by electroly on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:00PM (#35715863)
I've only done it once (the way they have it architected, it's a "set and forget" sort of thing, your LB changes don't touch the Global Accelerator) but I do seem to recall that it took awhile to create the resource. Maybe 5-10 minutes?
Re:Google cloud Europe is out by joelrwilliams1 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:26AM (#35727006)
5-10 minutes is accurate for creating and rolling out changes to a Global Accelerator
Re:Google cloud Europe is out by miyuru on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:57AM (#35715813)
> CloudFront is anycast-routed

This is false, cloudfront uses DNS (geo & latency) based load balancing.