Re:Magnet-hashes for all torrents on The Pirate Bay: 164 MB
by devindotcom on Thursday February 09, 2012 @05:32AM
(#3570536)
Totally true. As someone commented on my own story on this, you can kill someone in war and be a hero, or kill someone at home and get life in prison. Context and the definition provided by the law are very important. And as you say, the law doesn't have to be needlessly ignorant of the reality. It can easily encompass intent, result, context, etc.
But! There are still interesting problems to be acknowledged as far as how you define the transgression. A torrent like this from one perspective is worth billions, from another is worth very little. And practically speaking, if someone were to really use it the way you might expect a pirate to use it, it is practically worth only a tiny fraction of its potential worth. These are things that are difficult to define or restrict, but are immediately obvious to anyone who would use it. That's why it's interesting to me.
Re:Magnet-hashes for all torrents on The Pirate Bay: 164 MB
by anigbrowl on Thursday February 09, 2012 @05:10PM
(#3573349)
Sounds like we're on the same page. Legislative drafting is often overlooked in these things, I agree. A legal friend in the UK friend told me that way back when, the very best lawyers would get recruited to work at parliament writing and 'debugging' legislation, in order to maximize its legal reliability. Around the 1980s this came to be regarded as a waste of money and the budgets were slashed, and intead of the best lawyers legislative drafting fell to those who were unable to get decent jobs in the private sector...and the quality of legislation fell accordingly, while the cost of litigation soared. We're seeing a similar problem in American lawmaking nowadays, as best I can tell.
Law has certain resemblances to regular code, but folks here seem to think that if something isn't properly specified that the law will break in the same way that a program will fail to compile or run properly. But that's not how it works. Poorly drafted laws can fail, certainly, but it's not that hard to draft something that focuses on the end result.
Consider ordinary offences, such as robbery. You wouldn't get anywhere by arguing that you're alleged to have put your right hand in your pocket and pulled out a small hatchet, and that since there's no law specifically forbidding right-hand wielding of hatches, you should go free. The technicalities of how you committed the robbery are irrelevant as long as it can be established that you took someone's property in a violent fashion. I'm a little perplexed as to why folks think torrenting/piracy/filesharing etc. is so different that it can't be addressed legally. Sure, the law needs to be clear and logical, but only up to a point. It doesn't need to be absolutely exhaustive, and 'beyond a reasonable doubt' has never meant 'beyond any imaginable possibility'. People do make arguments like that in criminal defense cases from time to time, but they typically fail because the doubts they attempt to raise are absurdly far-fetched.