If we start shooting at satellites, there'll be much scarier things to worry about than how aviators will plot a course for landing. For better or worse, satellite warfare is the new Mutually Assured Destruction.
Sill, where's the dual technology system? When I got my IFR ticket, I shot an NDB and an ILS plus I had to know about GPS approaches (they weren't certified then). If I couldn't shoot an ILS at an airport, maybe I could pull off an NDB at my alternate. If your GPS broke you could use the NDBs to get a fix, your pitot freezes over you use pitch and power, your vacuum gyro fails you have an electric backup, etc. There was always a mix of methods. The beauty of the system was that you never depended on just one thing.
Is that gone now? It's all GPS or nothing? A solar flare takes out our GPS capability, and simply because "there'll be much scarier things to worry about" that means we're not as hosed?
Thanks again for the information. Just trying to sort out in my head what risks are being taken.
I love GPS, and I'm for using it more and more, but I have a philosophical problem with putting all of our eggs in one basket. Just like the military's reliance on stealth, this is really cool stuff -- until it stops working. Then you're worse off than before.
Maybe I'm just old cranky guy today.