News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Dark Side of the Mac App Store: Scam Apps and Shady D... by duxup on Sunday April 23, 2023 @03:16PM (#35679542)
I wonder if it possible to really quantify how difficult it is to get an bad acting app for any store approved?

We've all heard stories about random bans and apps black listed and so on. Happened to some folks I know.

Having said that ...

I worked on an app recently that used location data heavily. I was told all about how picky Apple (and they mentioned Google too) would be, from folks online, and at work. Some folks even suggested hiring someone who had managed to get an app approved to help us get it approved.

I asked that everyone calm down ... and just let me TRY submitting the damn app first before we decided we're climbing a tall mountain or whatever they thought.

I got right in to the App Store and Google Play ... no problem.

Now granted my app is REALLY up front about using location data and such. But I wonder what the story really is?

Re:The Dark Side of the Mac App Store: Scam Apps and Shady D... by iudqnolq on Sunday April 23, 2023 @03:21PM (#35679577)
I've heard (from random people) it's about whether the permission aligns with the category the app falls into.

A map app is assumed to have a legitimate purpose for location. But if you want to make a journalling app that automatically captures where you visit (like Apple just did) you'll have a hard time being allowed to make the argument.

Re:The Dark Side of the Mac App Store: Scam Apps and Shady D... by duxup on Sunday April 23, 2023 @03:27PM (#35679631)
That would make sense as far as my usage goes. The app revolves around logistics, it's a business focused app... all those things go hand in hand with location data.

I can imagine if a human saw it it would be a "yeah of course" kind of moment.

Some rando "free crossword puzzles", might get a closer look.

Re:The Dark Side of the Mac App Store: Scam Apps and Shady D... by transcriptase on Sunday April 23, 2023 @04:58PM (#35680546)
I still remember the early days when you needed a third party app to use your camera flash as a flashlight, and then having most of them request your contacts, location, and every other type of data that the OS would allow.
Re:The Dark Side of the Mac App Store: Scam Apps and Shady D... by NoZebra120vClip on Sunday April 23, 2023 @10:41PM (#35683097)
I really try to leverage builtin apps as much as possible. For example, I don't have a music playing app. I use "Files" and "Podcasts" which were preloaded. Files can play music for me just fine, because I don't have any playlists or sophisticated playback needs (I lied, I do have a few playlists made out of folders with files arranged just so.)

I don't really try to solve problems with 3rd party apps, like I don't have any adblocking, but I use NextDNS so the private DNS blocking is built in and I can use that from anywhere. I just use my default web browser and my default email reader and all that.

I think it's a fundamental type error that people tool up their little mobile device as if it's a desktop computer full of software. Again, I have little storage space to give over to a bunch of third-party cruft. So I use the preloaded apps to the best of their abilities, and I load stuff as I have a fundamental need or there's a paid service I'm accessing with them.

I uninstall apps frequently too. It is essential security review to reduce attack surface. I like how the Android 11 will revoke permissions that haven't been used in a while. It's good practice to remove your unused apps because then you are less likely to succumb to supply-chain attacks, among others.

Re:The Dark Side of the Mac App Store: Scam Apps and Shady D... by saagarjha on Monday April 24, 2023 @02:03AM (#35684176)
The story is that enforcement will vary depending on what specific type of review you go through.