Each checker will not do the digging themselves, rather, companies like Palantir will offer info products like "Individual Troll Quotient" or "Online Political Summary" which will be used in the same way credit profiles are for lending. This already exists above board with systems like Klout, and in the background a number of companies sell services like these to marketers.
Ultimately, the obnoxious-but-innocuous comments are just noise; it's the political views that run counter to the mainstream that will raise the most flags, and which require the most freedom from censorship, self- or otherwise.