Re:Star Trek as a purely symbolic artifact of past times
by ctdonath on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @01:16PM
(#3567692)
I've seen a moderately serious treatment that suggests that in a fight between our modern military and the Enterprise, the modern military might very well win.
Seems the Reddit-originated movie-bound story Rome Sweet Rome http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rome_Sweet_Rome has a similar issue with the Roman military vs well-equipped (but no resupply) Marines gone back to that age. Modernity works up to a point, but eventually it takes "boots on the ground" with massive resupply chains to win.
Re:Star Trek as a purely symbolic artifact of past times
by jfoutz on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @02:54PM
(#3568151)
The big E's one advantage is it's already in space.
Just tractor some asteroids and drop them in the ocean. Aside from the tsunami's, a few weeks of saltwater rain would make it really tough to feed 6 billion people.
Swing back by in a year, and then really fight with whoever is left.
I've seen a moderately serious treatment that suggests that in a fight between our modern military and the Enterprise, the modern military might very well win. The Enterprise does have the ability to slag its choice of ground target, and we'd have a hard time retaliating as long as it stayed in orbit, but that is pretty much all they could do. It seems it would be trivial to block their transporter, shuttles may be shielded but they seem to be slow and one imagine we could wear them down even with conventional weaponry, and Federation ground troops are laughably incompetent by real military doctrine standards, armed with a single line-of-vision ray weapon that immediately gives away their position every time they use it, somehow no air support, and their use of this weapon is also incompetent. Any modern military would chew them up on the ground, to say nothing of the elite ones.
Also it seems like any ol' script kiddie from real modern Earth would be able to penetrate their computer security by accident. The Federation seems to be incapable of writing a login screen without a cross-site scripting arbitrary code execution attack built right in and easily accessible in seconds from the keyboard.