News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Sell ∀ ∃ as ∃ ∀ Scam by cjbprime on Saturday April 22, 2023 @09:08PM (#35672393)
> Trivially explained as "even a broken clock is right twice a day."

Trivial, vacuous, and wrong. It is not plausible to correctly predict the output of a serious Python program by coincidence. See the detailed examples in the paper -- one of which was pseudocode, not Python -- to see how silly this claim sounds.

> First, it was published by Microsoft, a company that absolutely has a horse in this race

Firstly, this is evidence that you are neither very familiar with Microsoft, nor with academic or industrial research labs. Microsoft Research (the affiliation of the authors) is practically a different company, and run more like a university lab. It is somewhat deeply insulting to their (often still primarily academic) researchers to suggest that they would publish a misleading puff piece to benefit the commercial arm.

Secondly, while the paper describes itself as qualitative, you can reproduce the major claims yourself (and I have).

Re:The Sell ∀ ∃ as ∃ ∀ Scam by dvt on Saturday April 22, 2023 @09:38PM (#35672549)
> familiar with Microsoft, nor with academic or industrial research labs

The idea that Microsoft Research would publish anything remotely damaging to Microsoft is beyond naïve. I mean, one of their core tenets is "Ensure that Microsoft products have a future," but okay.