Re:Ask HN: Why do you contribute to open source?
by bryanlarsen on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @11:34AM
(#3567174)
In general terms, the key difference between a 'nice' group and a 'mean' group is the degree to whether the hierarchy in the group is obviously correct.
In the linux kernel, there is a clear hierarchy that is pretty close to being obviously correct. Linux obviously deserves to be the leader, and position/status is very clearly linked to a persons contributions to the greater good of the project.
On single person projects, the hierarchy is also trivially clear, obvious, correct and unassailable.
Many group projects fail the "clear hierarchy" test, often because they try to eliminate the hierarchy for some sort of ideals. But humans being human there is always some sort of hierarchy, so establishment of the hierarchy is informal and ongoing.
Of course, "informal and ongoing" is a lot better than 'wrong' which is the case with many clear hierarchies. This is why the idealism vis a vis trying to prevent hierarchies exists in the first place.
The obvious correctness of the hierarchy is one huge advantage small companies have over large companies and non-profits.
In the linux kernel, there is a clear hierarchy that is pretty close to being obviously correct. Linux obviously deserves to be the leader, and position/status is very clearly linked to a persons contributions to the greater good of the project.
On single person projects, the hierarchy is also trivially clear, obvious, correct and unassailable.
Many group projects fail the "clear hierarchy" test, often because they try to eliminate the hierarchy for some sort of ideals. But humans being human there is always some sort of hierarchy, so establishment of the hierarchy is informal and ongoing.
Of course, "informal and ongoing" is a lot better than 'wrong' which is the case with many clear hierarchies. This is why the idealism vis a vis trying to prevent hierarchies exists in the first place.
The obvious correctness of the hierarchy is one huge advantage small companies have over large companies and non-profits.