News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by phpisthebest on Saturday April 22, 2023 @02:31PM (#35669563)
I think you have just discovered the underlying goal of many climate activists.

The venn diagram of people that are climate activists and againt tons of things that would assist in reducing emissions is huge, a subset of these things include nuclear power, GMO's, Dam and other large scale earth works, etc.

This idea what we can just toss a few solar panels around and have no factory farms, and end meat production all with out these other technologies is either delusion or a belief in massive suffering and death.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by briantakita on Saturday April 22, 2023 @02:39PM (#35669635)
Solar panels & batteries are also made of toxic material. Mining & the material breakdown of these materials spead these toxins to the land they are deployed on.

Much of this material is also unethically mined. Children are coerced to mine some of this material.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by pfdietz on Saturday April 22, 2023 @02:59PM (#35669833)
What toxic material are x-Si panels made of?
Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by kalium-xyz on Saturday April 22, 2023 @03:20PM (#35670051)
Small amounts of cadmium and lead. Honestly you should not focus on that the batteries are the one that a legit argument is for imho. I’ve looked into why solar panels degrade over time and it’s mostly them physically being destroyed. The uv degradation happens very quickly and so isn’t gonna further ruin the panels output after its already been exposed a bit
Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by pfdietz on Saturday April 22, 2023 @05:03PM (#35670920)
x-Si panels require neither Cd nor Pb. What did you think the Cd was for, btw?
Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by Tagbert on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:13PM (#35671387)
Deploying the solar panels does not spread those elements in any significant way. They are bound up in the structure of the panels. In any case it is orders of magnitude less toxins that what is produced in drilling for oil and gas and burning them. Coal is on another scale entirely producing massive amounts of toxic byproducts. Solar is just a fart in the wind in comparison.
Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by vineyardmike on Saturday April 22, 2023 @03:52PM (#35670324)
Different activists have different goals. Assuming societal death is a goal is extremely uncharitable and wrong for the majority of activists.

For example, I believe that carbon emissions and the resulting climate change is the biggest climate issue we face.

I live in California, many people here are against damming because it will damage the natural environment where the reservoirs form. I think the reservoir damage is worth the “carbon cleanliness” of hydro power. Other people care more about preserving untouched nature more than the climate. They have different goals.

Still others think we should reduce consumption of resources like plastics because of their environmental impact. They may prefer more expensive or energy intense production methods and recycling methods.

Most activists won’t say something else is bad. Eg I think recycling is good, but I would prefer lower greenhouse emissions over lower trash. FWIW I don’t eat meat. It’s better for the environment, because it’s reduce emissions. It’s also less wasteful of water which is environmentally expensive. I don’t eat almonds for the same reasons. But I’d rather expend water if it reduced emissions, but I’m not sure of any examples where those are opposed, maybe with certain fabrics and their cost of production?

My jobs is also to reduce methane emissions at natural gas facilities, because in 2023 we need gas so let’s try to make it less polluting.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by phpisthebest on Saturday April 22, 2023 @04:29PM (#35670624)
>>Different activists have different goals.

while that is true, that is minority, I see ALOT of activists that actibly hold contradictory positions.

For example I have seen, ALOT of people (and I know you are not one of them) "I dont drink dairy milk because it is bad for the earth, instead I drink Almond Milk"..... ehhhhhh

Supplanting Almond Milk for Cow milk is a good position if you are doing it for animal ethics, but do claim you are saving the earth by doing it is non-sense.

>> I think recycling is good, but I would prefer lower greenhouse emissions over lower trash

This is not a contradictory position, it is sad the recycling movement has lost its way soo much..

The movement is/was REDUCE>REUSE>RECYCLE... is not just recycling. Some how we have skipped the first 2 and just worry about the last one. Part of that is need for the economy for always be consuming... so there is incentives by both government and corporations to get people to buy less durable less fixable goods.

This is why right to repair is critical to the environmental movement, but here again I have seen alot of climate activists posting from their iPhone how it is dangerous to allow people to fix their property..

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by runarberg on Sunday April 23, 2023 @12:59AM (#35673409)
I’m seeing more and more of this sentiment, particularly this simplistic tone which spreads FUD around the energy transition. I wonder where it is coming from.

But no, as somebody thoroughly on the left wing of the political spectrum, and a believer in most of the things you accuse climate activists of, I can attest that I’m a minority. I know a bunch of climate activists exists that have full faith that capitalism will solve the crises, some actually believe it has basically been solved (I call them climate optimists; and is a form of climate denialism).

However I do want to defend my camp here a little. Have you considered that perhaps we are right? GMO was supposed to end world hunger, or at least provide a global food security, it was pointed out at the time that no such thing would happen (as we already could have food security through more equal distribution). Now GMO is a pretty established technology that is rolled out in most of the world, and lo-and-behold, food security is still an issue.

Today I see nuclear power pitch similarly as a solution to global warming, however looking at the data, seeing different energy policies, where some countries keep building more reactors, others keep what they have, and some—but few—decommission and phase out nuclear power. What the data indicates is that nuclear power policy is pretty much irrelevant next to a policy of renewable proliferation and other energy savings measures. In other words it doesn’t matter. It can even be argued, because of the cost of nuclear power, that keeping them on is drawing away funds which could otherwise be used in more effective climate measures.