News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by Maursault on Saturday April 22, 2023 @02:26PM (#35669517)
> There are nutrients and amino acids only found in meat. Where do you get the replacement for this, what does that process look like, are they even metabolically equivalent?

Supplements are an easy solution, but I think what you're missing is that you don't necessarily need the massive amounts of those nutrients that is reflected by the meat industry. We certainly do not need to eat as much meat as the meat lobby wants us to eat. In fact, even by your nutrient argument, we need hardly any meat. In fact, of all the things we eat, the most amount of meat we'd need to eat, if we needed it at all, would be the smallest quantity amoung all those things. And really we don't necessarily need meat at all. Using a nutrient argument to support the eating of meat is a bad argument.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by saiya-jin on Saturday April 22, 2023 @02:59PM (#35669828)
Maybe things have changed but when I was a bit into weightlifting maybe a decade ago, common knowledge back then was that some forms of protein (ie amino acids mix of specific types and ratios) can't be realistically substituted by normally eating humans. I mean unless you want to prepare all your meals with scales.

Its not about theory on paper, but what people actually eat on a given diet and how their body looks long term. Its a fact that ie vegans lack: B12, D3, iron, taurine, creatine, iodine, calcium, zinc and have generally lower mineral bone density. Given that people with alternate lifestyles tend to take much more care into what they eat and focus on eating healthily and are well aware of this shortcoming, that's not a good result.

I mean lets have discussion about morality, sustainability etc. but when it comes to nutrients, science doesn't seem to be in favor of these alternate diets.

I personally wish people grokked that just reducing portions would bring massive improvements for everybody, including the planet. We simply eat too much (and definitely too much meat of any type), and often to full when it should be about avoiding hunger. I see 0 activism there, its harder to sell books, programs and overpriced supplements to desperate people rather than telling them this simple hard truth and having them actually accept it and act accordingly.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by Maursault on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:05PM (#35671327)
> some forms of protein... can't be realistically substituted by normally eating humans.

uh...

> Its a fact that ie vegans lack: B12,

Most vegans consume enough B12 to avoid clinical deficiency by eating foods fortified with B12, including plant milks, some soy products and some breakfast cereals, and B12 supplements

> D3,

The vegan source of vitamin D3 comes from algae, produces the most body-ready form of vitamin D3, cholecalciferol.

> iron,

Plant sources of iron include lentils, chickpeas, beans, tofu, cashew nuts, chia seeds, ground linseed, hemp seeds, pumpkin seeds, kale, dried apricots and figs, raisins, quinoa and fortified breakfast cereal.

> taurine,

Nori, the papery-like seaweed product used in making sushi, has up to 1,300 milligrams of taurine per 100 grams.

> creatine,

Supplements are sufficient.

> iodine,

Sea vegetables such as kelp, nori, kombu, wakame, and arame provide more than enough daily iodine. Common vegan thickeners such as carrageenan and agar-agar contain the mineral, too.

> calcium,

Sources of well-absorbed calcium for vegans include calcium-fortified soy milk and juice, calcium-set tofu, soybeans and soynuts, bok choy, broccoli, collards, Chinese cabbage, kale, mustard greens, and okra.

> zinc

Sources of zinc include beans, chickpeas, lentils, tofu, walnuts, cashew nuts, chia seeds, ground linseed, hemp seeds, pumpkin seeds, wholemeal bread and quinoa.

> and have generally lower mineral bone density.

Vegans avoid lower BMD by consuming plenty of plant-based foods containing calcium and vitamin D.

Eating meat has its own health risks, including a higher risk of ischemic heart disease, pneumonia, diabetes, diverticular disease, colon polyps and colorectal cancer. On average, those who engage in regular consumption of meat (three or more times per week) experience more adverse health consequences compared to those who consume meat less regularly.

But the biggest problem with eating meat is that meat industry is responsible for a large share of global greenhouse gas emissions. It contributes not only to global warming but also causes direct environmental pollution. People who eat a lot of meat can make a significant difference in the climate crisis by reducing or quitting meat consumption altogether. Even substituting other meat for beef would considerably reduce greenhouse gas emission.

In conclusion, meat sucks. I'm not a vegan, but my biggest gripe is meat is shoved down everyone throats. Nearly single restaurant, at least on the east coast, pretty much only serves meat dishes. Becoming a vegan is difficult because meat is literally everywhere, and animal product is in nearly all food products in some form or other, and even a large number of non-food products.

And there is simply too much meat in the US. There is a cow for every 3.5 people. An average cow, including calves and adults, weighs more than 1000lbs and produces nearly 650lbs. of meat. That's roughly 185lbs. of meat for every man, woman and child in the US, which would take a year to consume eating a half a pound of meat every day.

It's too much. There's way, way too much meat, and it is hurting everyone, everywhere. So please, don't be so pro-meat. Eat less of it, much less. You'll live longer and healthier, and your sacrifice will benefit everyone.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by least on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:04PM (#35672682)
> Most vegans consume enough B12 to avoid clinical deficiency by eating foods fortified with B12, including plant milks, some soy products and some breakfast cereals, and B12 supplements

No, they probably won't get enough with just fortified foods. Most vegans will need an actual B12 supplement.

> The vegan source of vitamin D3 comes from algae, produces the most body-ready form of vitamin D3, cholecalciferol.

This is true, except that people don't eat algae, so it's an additional supplement you need to take.

> Plant sources of iron include lentils, chickpeas, beans, tofu, cashew nuts, chia seeds, ground linseed, hemp seeds, pumpkin seeds, kale, dried apricots and figs, raisins, quinoa and fortified breakfast cereal.

All of which have low bioavailability which is why so many vegans have iron anemia. In fact eating mostly fibrous plants and seeds likely inhibits iron uptake.

> Nori, the papery-like seaweed product used in making sushi, has up to 1,300 milligrams of taurine per 100 grams.

It's likely to have less and once again, the issue comes down to bioavailability. It doesn't matter that it's in there if it cannot be processed by the human body.

> Sources of well-absorbed calcium for vegans include calcium-fortified soy milk and juice, calcium-set tofu, soybeans and soynuts, bok choy, broccoli, collards, Chinese cabbage, kale, mustard greens, and okra.

The phytates and oxalates in those inhibits calcium's bioavailability in these foods. You get it from supplements, once again.

> Sea vegetables such as kelp, nori, kombu, wakame, and arame provide more than enough daily iodine. Common vegan thickeners such as carrageenan and agar-agar contain the mineral, too.

You're more likely to meet your iodine needs from iodized salt. You need a reasonably large quantity of seaweed in your diet to actually meet your need for iodine. It's not problematic for some people, but it's just another list of things you need a specific amount of in order to just avoid malnutrition.

> Vegans avoid lower BMD by consuming plenty of plant-based foods containing calcium and vitamin D.

Yes, vegans have to jump through hoops to avoid malnutrition in their diet, which requires careful thought and planning. You do not avoid malnutrition just by eating a vegan diet and you will almost certainly be malnourished if you don't take supplements.

> But the biggest problem with eating meat is that meat industry is responsible for a large share of global greenhouse gas emissions.

It's also responsible for providing a reliable source of high quality protein which better matches what a human body needs. Livestock is nutritionally one of the best sources of food available to human beings. It does contribute a significant portion of greenhouse emissions, but so does agriculture in general. 14% of the 25% that agriculture contributes is livestock. If you completely removed livestock from the equation, emissions share for plant agriculture would increase and you'd be introducing more considerations that could also increase emissions. If I were to guess, it'd still be a net positive for emissions, but not as significant as people like to think.

> In conclusion, meat sucks. I'm not a vegan, but my biggest gripe is meat is shoved down everyone throats.

No, meat is great. It's an almost perfect food for humans. Vegetables, fruits, nuts, and grains are also great. Grains are probably the least great but they are important because they increase food security substantially and also serve as feed for livestock, which have their own benefits.

> Becoming a vegan is difficult because meat is literally everywhere, and animal product is in nearly all food products in some form or other, and even a large number of non-food products.

Vegan options are increasing a lot all over the country, including the East coast. But even if they weren't, eating out has a significantly higher carbon footprint than cooking a meal at home. You can cook for yourself which would decrease your carbon footprint along with your choice to eat vegan.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by Maursault on Sunday April 23, 2023 @11:24AM (#35677021)
All you've done is contradicted the statements I've made, which are verifiably true. I'm not sure why you would waste your time. Every statement you've made, every single thing you've just written, is provably false. Eat all the meat you want. You've earned it.
Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by least on Sunday April 23, 2023 @02:51PM (#35679326)
> Every statement you've made, every single thing you've just written, is provably false.

No, they're not.

> Most vegans will need an actual B12 supplement.

It obviously depends on how much of any given fortified B12 food you consume. Hypothetically yes, you could eat enough fortified foods to avoid the need for a pill, but it'd take a lot more intentional eating on the vegan's part. Most vegans should take a B12 supplement because it ensures that they're getting enough B12, while fortified foods have varied amounts of it.

https://www.vegansociety.com/resources/nutrition-and-health/...

> This is true, except that people don't eat algae, so it's an additional supplement you need to take.

I take this back, people do eat nori which is algae. It just doesn't contain vitamin d. Vegan would take a supplement, since vitamin D is not prevalent inside of plants. Another option might be UV-exposed mushrooms, but generally you either need fortified foods or a supplement. Vegan vitamin d supplements are produced from the algae you mentioned.

> All of which have low bioavailability which is why so many vegans have iron anemia. In fact eating mostly fibrous plants and seeds likely inhibits iron uptake.

Plant sources of iron do not contain heme iron, they contain non-heme iron, which is less bioavailable. 25% of heme iron and 17% of nonheme iron get absorbed, which seems insignificant until you realize exactly what that translates to in terms of how much material you need to consume to reach that.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK540969/

And on the bioavailability of iron:

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000291652...

On nori: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/319322455_The_Tauri...

The only source of 1300 mg claim that i saw was webmd... which is what you copied that sentence from.

> The phytates and oxalates in those inhibits calcium's bioavailability in these foods. You get it from supplements, once again.

Phytates play a larger role than oxalates. It's the same issue as with iron. Phytates bind with calcium which can prevent uptake.

Stop making impassioned statements trying to push an agenda you're unwilling to defend. My argument is defensible. It's quite possible I'm wrong about some of it, but it's certainly not driven by dogma.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by Maursault on Sunday April 23, 2023 @08:05PM (#35682075)
What you're missing is vegans have made a big decision and take their diet seriously. The fact of the matter is most vegans do not have a B12 deficiency, nor any of the other unsupported criticisms you've made. I honestly don't know how they can be so disciplined, and my only criticism of them is their often saying "it's easy," because I personally find it impossible to get away from animal product. There have been a lot of studies and surveys, and vegans do it, they avoid meat and animal product, and they're not all anemic and suffering from low BMD, in fact most are perfectly healthy because, again, they're serious about diet and nutrition, and disciplined, and they know what to eat. I guarantee you that most if not all vegans are a good sight healthier than you or I. The evidence is available on the web if you would just search and cease trying to confirm your biases. You're just trying to justify your lifestyle. Don't bother, because no one cares.
Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by least on Sunday April 23, 2023 @08:47PM (#35682367)
> The fact of the matter is most vegans do not have a B12 deficiency

I didn't say they did. I did say they in all likelihood need to supplement their B12. This is well supported by vegans and nutritionists.

> nor any of the other unsupported criticisms you've made.

I have supported my claims, actually. The fact that you disagree with the science is your problem, not mine.

> The evidence is available on the web if you would just search and cease trying to confirm your biases.

Your absolute lack of intellectual curiosity indicates that the one that would benefit from these words is yourself. You haven't actually discredited anything I've said even though this is all pretty well studied stuff. It's also important information for people that you seem to admire so much, to ensure that they are getting the right nutrition. Your argument is basically "I know vegans and they don't have any issues resulting from their diet." It's not an argument and it does a disservice to vegans to talk about it with such dishonesty.

> You're just trying to justify your lifestyle. Don't bother, because no one cares.

No, I'm making a case for meat, which you seem to have a really toxic relationship with on top of you being incredibly ignorant to the actual data.

You seem to be making the wrong assumption that I'm trying to dissuade people from becoming vegan. That's not what I'm doing. I am making an argument that meat is an excellent source of nutrition that has extremely high utility so the increased energy required to produce it is worthwhile.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by Maursault on Monday April 24, 2023 @09:47AM (#35687588)
> No, I'm making a case for meat

Well, that's not really possible. Meat is bad coming and going, objectively speaking. The only thing meat does have going for it is the energy provides, but at the cost of poor health and hurting literarily everyone. If meat producers weren't so greedy, and produced less, a lot less, only what was necessary, a lot of the harm that comes with meat could be mitigated, not the health risks, just the carbon contribution.

btw, any time I am mentioned, me personally, what I know or don't know, or what I am, etc. etc., a fallacious argument is being constructed. Fallacy is unpersuasive, fwiw.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by verdverm on Monday April 24, 2023 @01:29PM (#35690635)
You are not persuasive by showing your argument is based on your hate for something
Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by least on Monday April 24, 2023 @03:02PM (#35691692)
> The only thing meat does have going for it is the energy provides

Meat doesn't simply provide energy, it's a very nutritious food source. Livestock can and should be part of making our agriculture more sustainable.

> but at the cost of poor health and hurting literarily everyone.

Yes, we've established that you think the meat is bad, except you've not actually provided any evidence that it is bad.

> If meat producers weren't so greedy, and produced less, a lot less, only what was necessary, a lot of the harm that comes with meat could be mitigated, not the health risks, just the carbon contribution.

If any industry that contributes to greenhouse emissions produced less of what is causing those greenhouse emissions, that'd be a net good, probably. It's a balancing act between what people need for survival and what's good for the earth itself. Obviously you think that meat should be produced at a small fraction of the rate it's being produced at now, but I think that's got little to do with the environmental impact given how demonstrably dogmatic you've been throughout this conversation.

> btw, any time I am mentioned, me personally, what I know or don't know, or what I am, etc. etc., a fallacious argument is being constructed. Fallacy is unpersuasive, fwiw.

You've literally said that vegans are likely more healthy than I am and that I'm just trying to justify my lifestyle. When confronted with actual facts, you rejected them as bunk science. The cognitive dissonance you're experience is apparent.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by cfn on Sunday April 23, 2023 @02:10AM (#35673773)
So, basically, to avoid eating meat which is what we have been doing for thousands of years, we have to eat all kinds of pharmaceutical products to compensate the deficiencies of a plant based diet.

Are we accounting the costs of the production of these products in the comparison, and do we have conclusive, long term studies that suplements are as good as eating natural products? Apparently, the first suplements only appeared around 70 years ago.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by bigfudge on Sunday April 23, 2023 @02:37AM (#35673894)
No. Just eat less meat. We eat far more than is needed even according to the (disputed) literature suggesting meat is necessary for a balanced diet.

This doesn’t have to be a binary decision.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by least on Sunday April 23, 2023 @06:26AM (#35675005)
Alternatively, we eat as much meat and figure out how to reduce emissions in other ways. Meat production is part of the equation but its focus in these discussions seems largely agenda-based than anything else. It's a convenient scapegoat.

> according to the (disputed) literature suggesting meat is necessary for a balanced diet.

Meat being necessary hinges on veganism being a legitimate replacement. Is veganism legitimate as a full-on replacement? No, it's not. At least not yet. If or when it does become that, then yeah, meat won't be necessary. Right now it's mostly a viable option for relatively healthy adults with a lot of money to spend.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by bigfudge on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @03:10AM (#35697421)
Did you read my comment? It’s seems you are back to dichotomising to “just as much meat” Vs véganisme.

Why not just eat less meat?! No matter how it’s produced, there is a basic physics to this that means it’s always going to use more land than growing plants.

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by least on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:38AM (#35709947)
Maybe you're misunderstanding. My point is that maybe meat production in itself isn't something that really needs to be reduced because there's 1) ways to reduce its carbon footprint, 2) it's worth the cost it has on emissions because of its high utility.
Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by bigfudge on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @04:03AM (#35784640)
I understand your point now although I think both premises are entirely unreasonable. How about we find wsa to reduce emmisions first? There is no evidence of anyone successfully doing at present. On the second point, I think you’d need to substantiate the utility of excess meat first. The evidence seems to go the other way.
Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by Maursault on Sunday April 23, 2023 @10:10AM (#35676374)
> we have to eat all kinds of pharmaceutical products to compensate the deficiencies of a plant based diet.

Vitamin supplements are regulated by the FDA as food. They're not drugs or "pharmaceutical products."

Re:Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previousl... by porkbeer on Sunday April 23, 2023 @05:46PM (#35680977)
More correctly, they are almost completely unregulated.