The house my parents bought in 1975 is worth $4 million (according to Zillow) because it is in a prime Palo Alto location. In their case, assuming the house is actually worth $4M, they will make a tidy profit. They could buy a downsized house, but only if they move out of Palo Alto. And their tax bill would sky-rocket.
A better example might my house, which I have owned for 22 years, valued at a "mere" $1.4M. Taxes at market rate would be $12,320. Assuming I bought it in 1975, my yearly tax bill would be a mere $1,232. The first problem, small houses in the Bay Area are still expensive. But suppose I found something for $700K, my tax bill would go from $1,232 to $6,160. OK, maybe I move somewhere cheap, and get a house for $350K, I'm still probably paying more than 2x my current tax rate.
Add to that the enormous stress involved with buying a house, I'm not planning on selling, ever.
The first $500k is tax-free if married filing jointly. The rest is taxed at a maximum rate of 20%. For nearly $4m in profit, that's a pretty good deal. There'll be cash left after selling. Just pay the taxes.
> 6% of the sale price is split between the buying and selling realtor
You don't have to accept the standard shit deal in a seller's market like Palo Alto. Negotiate.
> And their tax bill would sky-rocket
Prop 90 allows homeowners over age 55 to keep their original assessed value when selling and moving to a different home of equal or lesser value. [1]
To me it sure sounds like your parents could sell for $4m, buy a high-end condo in Mountain View or Sunnyvale for $1.5m, and have close to $2m left over after taxes, closing costs, and moving expenses. And continue to enjoy low property taxes on their new place. Maybe I missed something though.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1988_California_Proposition_90
This is orthogonal to housing delivering real returns. (Common cause, granted.)
Help me out with this. Their downsized home will cost less than their large home sells for.