Sharpness is relative.
At 40 I'm definitely not as sharp as I was at 20. I mean... Give me a leetcode challenge today, and I'll flunk a lot of them.
The core of the arbitration decision is that "election data" specifically meant "packet captures of machines related to the election," relying on the fact that pretty much everyone (sans Lindell) understood that that was the kind of data they expected to have. Lindell instead had a tactic of relying on him being the ultimate arbiter of what satisfied "election data" as an ultimate get-out-of-jail-free card (which likely could have run afoul of other good-faith laws, although arbitration didn't analyze that point because they didn't need to go that far).
It's really surreal to remember how unstrange it was at that point. Hair dye dripping down Guiliani's face as spearheaded a blatant lie everyone knew was a lie whilst trying to overturn an election. Just completely insanity all around, and yet, it didn't feel that far off from everything that had preceded it. Just the frog getting a little hotter.
The claim was very specific: Prove this data isn't from the 2020 election. All you had to do was actually include 2020 election data in the set. And right there, the problem becomes much harder.
Hell, you could have just used a dump of 2020 election data and been fine. Just claim it proves your accusations.
And that's probably part of the reason that they worded the challenge like that. Because it's the easiest one to manufacture reasonably well. Yet they still fucked it up.
I still cannot believe how anyone can believe in the competence of anyone in Trump's political sphere after the Four Seasons fiasco. How often does one have to kick themselves square in the dick before people start wondering if they're not the sharpest bulb in the box?