Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by 1880 on Tuesday February 07, 2012 @06:33PM
(#3564213)
Relevant:
"Symantec was prepared for the code to be posted at some point and has developed and distributed a series of patches since Jan. 23rd to protect pcAnywhere users against known vulnerabilities." [1]
If I am understanding this correctly, there were existing and known vulnerabilities that are being patched now because the source was published?
It looks like open source does make software more secure :)
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by sev on Tuesday February 07, 2012 @06:31PM
(#3564205)
I'm not sure I understand the motive of this, other than saber rattling. Are they really fighting for everything to be open sourced to this extreme extent? Or should we assume this is the "script-kiddie" arm of Anon doing this as opposed to the more "noble"[1] work we see sometimes?
[1]debatable, and none of the above is necessarily what I believe
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by redthrowaway on Tuesday February 07, 2012 @07:14PM
(#3564342)
This is the AntiSec arm, which basically decided to simply attack security vendors and contractors to show them as snake oil salesmen. It wasn't really related to any sort of moral vision or goal, just fucking things up.
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by rbanffy on Tuesday February 07, 2012 @07:56PM
(#3564470)
This has absolutely nothing to do with open-source. Please, don't confuse things. Also, it's not because the source code is now public that it became open.
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by kooshball on Thursday February 09, 2012 @12:37AM
(#3569974)
I dont know where you got that from. If you read the email thread it's clear Anon was asking for money from the beginning. It's clear extorsion. How is that at all Symantec trying to bribe them?
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by Turing_Machine on Tuesday February 07, 2012 @06:57PM
(#3564285)
I guess I'm surprised that anyone is still using it, given the proliferation of FOSS VNC software and the fact that both OS X and Windows now have their own remote desktop capability. Does pcAnywhere offer advantages over these?
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by bwarp on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @06:15AM
(#3566098)
It has the same advantage that any paid anti-virus has over a free one i.e. some sense that because you've paid for something it must be better. Or in plain English, no advantage at all.
The irony is that Windows has had damn near perfect remote desktop support since 2002. How they've hung on for 10 years is beyond me.
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by jetsnoc on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @12:30AM
(#3565237)
Wow! I'm intrigued and curious by what the "time bomb word docs" might contain. I don't really want the feds knocking on my door! Guess I will have to take a pass pulling this source code apart.
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by greatquux on Saturday February 11, 2012 @12:05PM
(#3579580)
I have one customer that uses it to remotely access Bloomberg terminals because the Bloomberg software can detect if you're connecting via remote desktop and bar access to it. Of course, after this, I'll be transitioning them to VNC...
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by derleth on Tuesday February 07, 2012 @06:45PM
(#3564248)
So is Anonymous going to be the Malcolm X to RMS's Martin Luther King, Jr.? Shift the Overton Window to make the GPL look like the most moderate, reasonable option?
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by blasdel on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @01:03AM
(#3565333)
Yes, quite like the difference between nonviolent protest for integration and armed militant separatism as independent attempts at dissolving the white man's oppression of african-americans.
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by tsotha on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @03:59AM
(#3565825)
No I didn't. He was trying to imply these things are somehow poles on the same scale. They're not. For one thing, FOSS is already seen as perfectly reasonable by everyone but PR flacks from Microsoft and Oracle.
It's more like your idiot kid brother robs a bank, and now nobody in the neighborhood trusts you any more.
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by metajack on Tuesday February 07, 2012 @06:29PM
(#3564201)
What in the world do you think this has to do with the FSF? How is releasing proprietary code at all similar to open sourcing it?
I'm really failing to understand how you made this association or why you think their intent was driven by desire to expose all code. From the torrent description it appears they are trying to out something that Symantec did wrong, not simply release the code.
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by angersock on Tuesday February 07, 2012 @06:42PM
(#3564236)
They opened the source to the world, did they not?
(yes, yes, I know the difference, but in the right light this is funny, no? Releasing the source code has gone beyond mere piracy to active liberation!)
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by rbanffy on Tuesday February 07, 2012 @08:02PM
(#3564491)
If you know the difference, why mention the FSF?
Not only this code is not free, it's toxic. If anyone does or wants to work on free or open source software, I suggest not even looking into this codebase.
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by libcee on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @01:03AM
(#3565334)
i realize that copyleft proponents and permissive license proponents tend to have different views, but painting everyone that disagrees with you as "zealots" and taking cheap pot shots like the ones you see increasingly on hn is pretty intellectually dishonest.
everyone knows that open source has successfully overshadowed free software. no need to continue to marginalize them more than has already been done, you win. they'll try forever to be taken seriously, and everyone will try very hard to miss the point.
also, while a lot of people on hn seem to think that permissive licensing is the only way to do it, most copyleft proponents do think there is a place for permissive licensing. so pretending it's the people calling for more than one solution "zealots" is especially silly.
tl;dr but as long as you outnumber them, you can tell everyone they're the zealots, and as long as you outnumber them you can win the argument (the accusation) by popular support. 100 million open source advocates can't be wrong, (and even if they were, who cares?)
Re:Anonymous releases stolen Symantec source code
by gumbo on Tuesday February 07, 2012 @07:35PM
(#3564397)
I've gone throught the email conversation, i feel like they didn't really just wanted the money.
A blackmailer don't just ask:
"SO - you told us a week ago that you've being requesting a
response from Fin dprtmnt. We got no answer for the below question
so far:
?How much do you consider ENOUGH to pay us in order to
work all the issues out?
"Symantec was prepared for the code to be posted at some point and has developed and distributed a series of patches since Jan. 23rd to protect pcAnywhere users against known vulnerabilities." [1]
If I am understanding this correctly, there were existing and known vulnerabilities that are being patched now because the source was published?
It looks like open source does make software more secure :)
[1]: http://www.symantec.com/theme.jsp?themeid=anonymous-code-cla...
I await for someone brave enough to get the source and publish a security analysis.
[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Full_disclosure
[2]http://risky.biz/lulzsec
[1]debatable, and none of the above is necessarily what I believe
Symantec was the one offering the bribe. Well it wasn't even Symantec, they lied, it was FBI.
Either I am completely misteading Gizmodo or they are lying. In either case it seems too late to remove the post.
The irony is that Windows has had damn near perfect remote desktop support since 2002. How they've hung on for 10 years is beyond me.
You missed his analogy completely.
It's more like your idiot kid brother robs a bank, and now nobody in the neighborhood trusts you any more.
"Ve vill free all ze codes! Open zource everyzing!"
In all seriousness, though, this is not helping the community or fellow anons.
I'm really failing to understand how you made this association or why you think their intent was driven by desire to expose all code. From the torrent description it appears they are trying to out something that Symantec did wrong, not simply release the code.
(yes, yes, I know the difference, but in the right light this is funny, no? Releasing the source code has gone beyond mere piracy to active liberation!)
Not only this code is not free, it's toxic. If anyone does or wants to work on free or open source software, I suggest not even looking into this codebase.
everyone knows that open source has successfully overshadowed free software. no need to continue to marginalize them more than has already been done, you win. they'll try forever to be taken seriously, and everyone will try very hard to miss the point.
also, while a lot of people on hn seem to think that permissive licensing is the only way to do it, most copyleft proponents do think there is a place for permissive licensing. so pretending it's the people calling for more than one solution "zealots" is especially silly.
tl;dr but as long as you outnumber them, you can tell everyone they're the zealots, and as long as you outnumber them you can win the argument (the accusation) by popular support. 100 million open source advocates can't be wrong, (and even if they were, who cares?)
"SO - you told us a week ago that you've being requesting a response from Fin dprtmnt. We got no answer for the below question so far: ?How much do you consider ENOUGH to pay us in order to work all the issues out?
"
He know what the value of what he got.