Re:Substack Is the Biggest Threat to Newsletters Ever
by phpisthebest on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:03PM
(#35633307)
I think that is more telling of the substack content you were reading, This is like people that complain YT feeds them more of the same content they watched??
If read a bunch of stacks that are complaining about social change why would you expect substack to recommend you sports content....
>>After a while, you will get tired of that narrative.
You might, others do not.
Re:Substack Is the Biggest Threat to Newsletters Ever
by fullshark on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:45PM
(#35633117)
Agreed, the disgruntled are the only people willing to pay specific journalists with specific missions to effect change. Everyone else would just either pay a flat fee for general information about X, or would pay nothing.
Re:Substack Is the Biggest Threat to Newsletters Ever
by xapata on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:05PM
(#35633326)
You may be suffering from a recommendation system flaw. I subscribe to several Substack newsletters and have no content similar to what you've described. Instead, I read mostly about economics and parenting.
Re:Substack Is the Biggest Threat to Newsletters Ever
by nonethewiser on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:15PM
(#35633420)
You’re uncritically equating disgruntled to niche. It seems to me that the disgruntled view is the mainstream view.
Jonathan Haidt is an interesting example. He’s basically the foremost expert on an emergent problem.
Re:Substack Is the Biggest Threat to Newsletters Ever
by Invictus0 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:52PM
(#35633186)
Strongly disagree. I read finance news and stock writeups on Substack and the platform has a vibrant community in this category. Newsletters like Grit, Doomberg, The Science of Hitting, and others are doing great, valuable work and have pretty big followings.
Today I saw a substack article on HN's top list from Jonathan Haidt, another guy in the same political spectrum complaining about social media and societal change.
My impression of substack is that, it is the platform of the disgruntled. Substack is a niche player, and never will be mainstream.