News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by mawadev on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:18AM (#35627202)
It is truly remarkable to which great lengths people go to justify their unhealthy relationship with social media. It is nearly the same as telling an alcoholic they have an alcohol problem and then hearing excuse after excuse and re-framing and mental gymnastics to jump around the elephant in the room.

I'm glad write-ups like this one are a thing.

Maybe our parents were indeed right when they told us we are glued to our devices and should go touch grass.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by creshal on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:26AM (#35627266)
> Maybe our parents were indeed right when they told us we are glued to our devices and should go touch grass.

And yet, their generation seems to be the most addicted these days, and the most unhinged when it comes to following conspiracy theories.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by taneq on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:54AM (#35627533)
Well of course they are, they poor dears grew up in a world without it and while there are exceptions, most of them lack any natural immunity. Just look at people over 50 (present company excepted, of course) trying to use the web without an ad blocker.
Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by ChrisMarshallNY on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:55AM (#35627545)
This is a good point.

I suspect that one reason is that "digital natives" have been raised with the tech, so have sort of a "natural resistance," yet the oldtimers were hooked almost immediately.

For myself, I have been using electronic communications, almost since they were invented (BBSes and UUNet, anyone?), so I have "more resistance" than most of my peers.

Yet, I still have to stay off of Facebook. This is pretty much my only social media venue. The main reason I stay, is because people play [relatively] nice, hereabouts.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by jt2190 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:57AM (#35627561)
I suspect that those who grow up as social media “natives” will have some social norms that protect them somewhat, whereas many of those who came of age pre-social media will not have learned the social norms that can protect them.

We can see lots of useful examples of a protective social norms with alcohol. For example, it’s quite common for people to not drink any alcohol before a certain hour of the day. It’s not illegal to drink alcohol earlier, but it’s “just not done”. We can easily see the benefits of not drinking at the start of the workday.

I’m not going to guess what kind of social media norms people are developing in general. For me I only follow boring, topic-focused people on Twitter, and I only use the “Following” feed. Nobody is making me do this.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by polygotdomain on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:44AM (#35628043)
>I suspect that those who grow up as social media “natives” will have some social norms that protect them somewhat, whereas many of those who came of age pre-social media will not have learned the social norms that can protect them.

Agreed. A lot of older generations fall for a lot of satire and comment on things as if they're 1 on 1 with you instead of realizing that it's a public forum. However, a lot of younger generations are incredibly aware that everything they do and say could potentially be public or go viral. That brings a whole host of other problems and challenges with it.

The ultimate problem is every incentive goes against a "healthy" social media. Companies don't want a "healthy" social media as they're focused on engagement, screen time, content, and advertisers. Most of the primitive portions of our brains don't want "healthy" social media either, as it craves the rush of more likes and followers. I don't think that the logical, self-aware portions of our psyche are going to change the direction of how things are going.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by jwestbury on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:54AM (#35628161)
> We can see lots of useful examples of a protective social norms with alcohol. For example, it’s quite common for people to not drink any alcohol before a certain hour of the day. It’s not illegal to drink alcohol earlier, but it’s “just not done”.

I find this point quite interesting. I didn't drink alcohol until I was nearly 30. I skipped by most of the formative alcohol consumption experiences most people have.

And, incidentally, I don't seem to follow the same norms about what time of day it's okay to drink: I'll happily have a beer well before noon.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by polishdude20 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @10:00AM (#35628232)
The non-native social media people have grown up fully on in-person relationships where trust is very important. They apply the same trust to people on social media that they do to their friends and family. The social media natives treat social media as different things.
Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by 1827162 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:59AM (#35627582)
Likely because that generation was raised to believe everything they were told, starting from an early age with school, religion, then with television and newspapers, etc.

The younger generation were raised with media that spread obvious untruths such as conspiracy theories, pseudoscience, etc. and they learned to think more critically about what they are reading.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by dexterdog on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:28AM (#35627880)
That is an awfully broad brush you are painting with there. It's also painfully obvious which of the two groups you are in.
Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by 1827162 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:31AM (#35627918)
Yes, quite possibly overgeneralization there. Thinking on it....
Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by taeric on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @10:37AM (#35628713)
I'm probably over indexing on it, but the nocebo effect did not begin and end with a generation. People are remarkably influenced by what they are told. Even if they know it is unlikely or not true.
Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by zozbot234 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @11:11AM (#35629138)
> The younger generation were raised with media that spread obvious untruths such as conspiracy theories, pseudoscience

Except that talk radio is way older than that, and it was the same kind of content.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by 1827162 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @11:15AM (#35629197)
Yes, I'm likely wrong there....

As a side note, one important change in the modern times is the ability to cross check information from a wide range of sources easily.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by oh_sigh on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @10:43AM (#35628778)
Not according to this:

Social media, gen z wins: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1314973/global-daily-tim...

Phones in general, millennials win: https://www.entrepreneur.com/business-news/which-generation-....

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by hasmolo on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:26AM (#35627268)
this glued to devices meme is tired. look at a picture of folks on public transport from before phones. note that _everyone_ is reading a newspaper or magazine. i know it seems crazy, but humans reading information is a constant in public, and the only reason you didn't see more of it in the past is that you were part of the group consuming media, while also assigning intellectual value to the fact that a periodical is 'printed on paper' as if destroying a tree to make paper legitimizes the content in some way that a digital download of the same content can't.

get a better argument

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by n4r9 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:39AM (#35627394)
That's like saying there's nothing wrong with giving thalidomide to pregnant women, because pregnant women have always taken herbal supplements.

The obvious difference is that newspapers contain a relatively small amount of information packaged in a non-interactive, non-targeted, and less mind-absorbing format. People don't read newspapers for the dopamine hit, but for lack of something else to do.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by idontknowifican on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:51AM (#35627498)
that’s not true at all. the process of learning is a dopamine hit. the concept that phones made us antisocial is dumb, it’s a default. arguing to end phones avoids dealing with the problem
Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by n4r9 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @11:45AM (#35629642)
> the process of learning is a dopamine hit

Perhaps reading newspapers produces some dopamine, but I imagine it is tiny in comparison to the effects of smartphones, and does not provide the user with the easy option to keep scrolling for more dopamine.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by Gordonjcp on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:07AM (#35627659)
> That's like saying there's nothing wrong with giving thalidomide to pregnant women, because pregnant women have always taken herbal supplements.

Your analogy is better than you think, because in fact there isn't anything wrong with giving pregnant women thalidomide at all!

You just have to not do it within a very carefully defined range of time within pregnancy, but before and after that it's as safe as milk.

Turns out, the same process that makes thalidomide horribly teratogenic also makes it an absolutely first-rate cancer drug with few side-effects even in pregnancy.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by n4r9 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @11:55AM (#35629764)
Interesting. I've looked for sources on that and found a couple of sites saying that the sensitive period is 20-37 days after conception, but come up short of studies on anything later.

This webpage seems to suggest the risks are unknown after first trimester: https://mothertobaby.org/fact-sheets/thalidomide-pregnancy/

Same from this university classroom material (p.2): https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/MediaLibraries/URMCMedia/life...

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by AlexandrB on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:36AM (#35627360)
Newspapers and magazines didn't microtarget their audience or have endless streams of content. This is like saying "look at all the people riding horses in old pictures, cars can't be that bad".

That's not even getting into the level of corporate surveillance social media and online advertising have brought us.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by idontknowifican on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:54AM (#35627528)
what on earth are you talking about? newspapers have existed to control the narrative since inception. look at how they’ve been used, and listen to the lead editors talk about using their influence.

it’s a slightly less targeted ad, sure, but my dad only reads conservative papers, and they don’t seem to be written with a common perspective

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by max51 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @01:02PM (#35630574)
The difference is that a new article carefully chosen to fit your preferences doesn't magically appear on your lap every time you finish reading (or rejecting if you don't like it) the previous one. You also can't swift quickly through hundreds of headlines to pick what interest you the most when you are dealing with physical medias. You are stuck with whatever you brought with you.
Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by freejazz on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:55PM (#35633798)
> newspapers have existed to control the narrative since inception

That's not even remotely close to what they said and is clearly just your own personal grievance with newspapers

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by switch007 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:36AM (#35627362)
* * *
Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by idontknowifican on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:52AM (#35627506)
yes, but my experience is speaking to caltrain in the 90s
Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by reaperducer on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:57AM (#35627557)
look at a picture of folks on public transport from before phones. note that _everyone_ is reading a newspaper or magazine.

I know the image you have in your mind. I've seen it, too.

What you actually mean is "I saw this one picture on social media of a bunch of people on a train all reading newspapers at the same time because war just broke out."

Using that as a logical crutch for social media addiction is like the alcoholic saying "everybody does it."

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by Gordonjcp on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:07AM (#35627666)
I grew up in the 1980s. Everyone sat and read a newspaper or a book on the bus or the train back then.
Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by watwut on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:13AM (#35627728)
> note that _everyone_ is reading a newspaper or magazine

There is one popular picture where everyone is reading newspapers in a bus. And just like now it is not true that everyone is reading on phone on public transport. It was even less so before, because not everybody carried magazines with them all the time.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by vehemenz on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @10:09AM (#35628360)
Narrative content is not the same as interactive content. The quality of the content is not the same. I'm not sure what compelled you to make your point in the presence of such obvious points.

This is quite a big pond, my friend. The "get a better argument" line might go over well in your social circle, but HN is a big place with many smart people. Have some humility.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by warner25 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @10:34AM (#35628680)
I don't think the issue with phones is that people aren't engaging with each other in public spaces. I'll stipulate that it has never been the norm to engage with strangers on public transport. But I see a number of other differences between then and now.

For one, I don't think it was common for people to take a newspaper out of their pocket and look at it during social events with friends and family whenever conversation slowed down for a moment, or whenever it pinged with a notification. I observe my own wife spending far more time looking at her phone today than she ever spent reading a book before. Ten years ago, she might get lost in a book for a day or two, if it was a really good one. Now she walks around the house with her phone in-hand at all times. I had to pry myself back from that after starting to notice the same behavior in myself.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by barbazoo on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @01:57PM (#35631227)
> look at a picture of folks on public transport from before phones.

That's a strawman, the issue is kids spending their time on devices rather than outside doing real play with real people. That sort of thing.

Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by data_eng_dude on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:44AM (#35627438)
At least with alcohol it's more socially acceptable to say to friends "I've seen how much you've been drinking lately and I'm concerned about you" - you can't really say the same for tiktok or instagram use.
Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by zamnos on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:37AM (#35627980)
Sure you can. Well maybe you can't, but the kids these days even have a phrase for it - go touch grass.
Re:Why Some Researchers Think I’m Wrong About Social Media a... by OkayPhysicist on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @02:06PM (#35631329)
Yeah, there's a whole lexicon around this sort of thing. "Go touch grass" is a fantastic one for it's punchiness, but "terminally online" is fun one, too. Add in a healthy dose of sarcasm, and labels like "influencer" and "gamer" and the like get used as pejoratives often, too.