News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by rhaway84773 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @03:25PM (#35618778)
This is backwards. Capital expenses are amortized because you purchase an asset that will give you value over multiple years. So, for example, if you buy an office building, you amortize the capital expense.

But what this does is says that if the product you created is an asset, the salaries that go into creating that asset should be treated as if it were purchasing that asset. The office building equivalent would be the builder having to treat the salary it paid its labor as a capital expense and amortizing it.

That sounds beyond insane.

That being said, it’s not a material change, if phased in properly, so companies have time to spread their expenses over a period of time.

But it looks like neither was this planned for (not surprising because it’s ridiculous on its face), nor does the legislation phase it in a manner that can be properly absorbed.

In practice companies will get hit hard the first year, but save the equivalent amount over the next 3-4 years. So after 5 years it will be a wash (ignoring the time value of money…factoring in that makes it a loss, but not as much of a loss). The problem is that it will create tremendous cash flow problems as 5 years of tax is paid in 1 year.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by amluto on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @03:58PM (#35619204)
> Capital expenses are amortized because you purchase an asset that will give you value over multiple years. So, for example, if you buy an office building, you amortize the capital expense.

Even that seems like a pretty weak argument for what is essentially a tax penalty.

At least for a purchase of a liquid (or somewhat liquid) capital asset, one could, in principle, re-sell it. But most R&D has essentially no direct resale value and is not being done to create a salable asset. It’s done to create knowledge or IP, which, in turn, is used to create something salable.

I assume the purpose of requiring amortization of capital expenses is to prevent abuses like buying an extremely liquid asset, deducting the purchase price, and thus deferring a tax bill.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by dfkljsdlakj on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:02PM (#35619244)
> The office building equivalent would be the builder having to treat the salary it paid its labor as a capital expense and amortizing it.

If the builder is building the thing for themself, they do in fact have to depreciate over the IRS-provided lifespan of the building.

The software equivalent to a builder is an agency. If the agency is building their own software, they now have to do the same thing. If the agency is building for someone else, they expense the labor immediatley.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by ricardobayes on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:08PM (#35619321)
Honestly if a company's business model revolved around getting 100% tax credits for dev salaries, that company should in fact go away. A 100% rebate on taxes on an already high margin and low expense business segment just feels wrong.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by dahfizz on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:40PM (#35619755)
If the company has high margins and low expenses, then their profits are already taxed. Its not like hiring one SWE makes your tax bill go to zero.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by grumple on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:46PM (#35619846)
It's not a rebate, it's salary. For a company bringing in 1 million in revenue and paying 1 million in salary, they literally don't have any money in the bank to pay taxes because they haven't profited yet. If they profit the next year because of their new "asset" giving them long term benefits, they would pay then.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by jakear on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @05:23PM (#35620418)
Isn't the simple solution to just not give away all of your revenue before you pay your taxes?

The two constants are death and taxes, if you don't have the revenue to pay them at your current burn rate, you either find a way to burn less or your company just isn't viable.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by vikramkr on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @06:11PM (#35621086)
The idea of corporate taxes is to tax profits, not revenue
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by jakear on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @06:27PM (#35621297)
Which just ends up with corporate accountants structuring the books to minimize "profit".

I for one can't find it in me to get all that upset about startups paying their fair share of taxes instead of artificially inflating salaries to consume all of their "revenue", thereby hoarding talent away from the labor pool that would likely better serve the country as a whole by working in... really anything besides risky chronically unprofitable startups.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by vikramkr on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @07:31PM (#35621981)
What's wrong with paying employees more? Income tax is a thing and that's on revenue, not profit. You'll get a bigger cut of that then other expenses. And a bigger cut of that than equity comp and share buybacks where that's cap gains. Income is great!
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by jakear on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:40PM (#35622643)
Are you arguing the government is actually getting less tax this way?
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by vikramkr on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:41PM (#35671565)
For the economic activity that happened this year, yeah they get more by forcing people to delay recognizing expenses, which is essentially an interest free loan for the irs that they don't have to pay back if the lender goes bankrupt. But this doesn't actually create a new nominal tax increase, in nominal dollars its a wash, and so the question is if the interest free loan is worth the decrease that would result from companies finding more tax efficient ways to pay employees and any decrease in future economic activity this will cause. Corporate tax and cap gains tax are likely lower than the income tax bracket those revenues would have gone to as income.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by bcrosby95 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:26PM (#35622539)
Why are you so hostile to startups? Maybe if you could articulate what small software companies are actually abusing when they offset their revenue with wages like literally every other industry out there I could start to understand your viewpoint.

But without that you just seem like you have a chip on your shoulder.

You do understand that if this law were applied to any industry it would similarly kill small companies in those? Like if restaurants had this rule for wages it would devastate smaller, family run restaurants.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by jakear on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:35PM (#35622606)
I'm simply stating the idea the P's present of "How terrible is this? I made 1,000,000, spent 1,000,000, but now I don't have money for taxes!" is quite literally a lesson any kid should have learned when they first went to the store to buy a $5 candy with a $5 bill and learned the way of the world.

Given restaurants aren't in the business of R&D I don't see why you're trying to make an argument based on applying R&D tax law to them. It's disingenuous, at best.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by eldavido on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @10:30PM (#35623574)
>But what this does is says that if the product you created is an asset, the salaries that go into creating that asset should be treated as if it were purchasing that asset.

This is precisely what happens!!