News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firmware is on shaky ground – let's see what it's made of by mindslight on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:00AM (#35614879)
In a past life I was an embedded designer, and I think your observation is spot on! While the libre enthusiast in me would love to be able to inspect and possibly modify bona fide firmware, I do respect that say tweaking the code on a power supply or motor controller is fraught with hazards (you want to use a debugger? while the microcontroller is stopped, your circuit cooks. you want to use printf? the additional cycles make your circuit cook ...)

But there are tons of companies abusing the term for software that is actually being continually updated, and/or isn't hardware critical at all (eg Intel ME). The use of "firm" here is entirely prescriptive, for the manufacturer's business reasons of locking out end-users, rather than because the code is akin to fixed hardware.

A simple test might actually just be the desire to modify/repair. Nobody wants to really dig into a power supply controller unless it's doing something very broken that needs be fixed. Meanwhile what creates the most e-waste is the ending of software updates, which are most certainly not firmware.

There are no comments on this comment yet.