Yes and no. I might have a fantastic SO profile, but be utterly unable to communicate face-to-face, or in stressful situations. I think it's important to remember these possibilities...
Re:Farewell Stack Exchange
by malnourish on Monday February 06, 2012 @07:29PM
(#3559886)
So an attribute used in tandem with others?
Another problematic aspect is that someone may be very good at formulating an answer but requires the use of internet resources e.g. google, other SO answers. This coincides with your face-to-face example.
Such a talent would have its uses, but may not be as useful in certain situations as someone whose answers may be slightly less quality but composed without exterior information.
I imagine a world, reminiscent of Ender's Game, where online discussion holds much sway and credence, and the separation between it and "the real world" exists only to differentiate physical properties.
It would seem that we are slowly approaching this more transparent mesh of societies.
If a person can empirically show their value and experience with a topic, as you did with your SO profile, it should hold the same regard as similar measures.