Re:Show HN: Google Analytics alternative with the most gener...
by JackWritesCode on Friday April 14, 2023 @04:04PM
(#35573988)
Fathom's script forgets everybody by default, it's literally built into the tech. No EU personal data is touching Canada.
The background of Schrems II was that the US government can compel US companies to track foreign nationals and it would be lawful under US law. This is where the argument of "company in X under Y laws" comes into play. For example, Amazon is a US company. An EU subsidiary is still subject to it's parents control. If that parent is a US company, it's subject to US surveillance laws. Hello Schrems II.
So I'm not fully following why we're having a discussion around processing happening in Canada when personal data (IP Address) hits our EU Isolation infrastructure.
If you have any sources you can cite where the European Commission states BC as an exemption to Canada's adequacy ruling, please throw it back to me. I've not seen that.
RE: 1
I am looking at this document: https://www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca/civix/document/id/complete/stat...
I assume this is up-to-date.
I will take one example: the Right to be forgotten. I don't see provision that satisfies the right to be forgotten: https://gdpr.eu/right-to-be-forgotten/
You seem to have a more in-depth understanding of PIPA. Can you point me towards a similar requirement in PIPA?
RE 2:
Right, I was referring to the fact that customers of Fathom sign contract/get into agreement with a company in British Columbia under its laws. It is mostly irrelevant where their CTO resides (it would be relevant if you resided in a non-adequate country, as your privacy policy would have to account for relevant data transfers).