News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by londons_explore on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:41AM (#35553933)
* * *
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by arcbyte on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:48AM (#35553989)
They used to do public betas. I remember Gmail being labeled beta in the early days.
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by amenghra on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:55AM (#35554043)
Gmail was in beta for 5 years, from 2004 until 2009 — imho it didn’t make much sense to label something as beta when it is used by ~1B people.
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by kmlx on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:59AM (#35554091)
i think it's about expectations
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by londons_explore on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:05AM (#35554136)
Thing is... imagine they had announced "Thanks for being part of the gmail beta. We learnt a lot, but have now decided to close GMail. You have 3 days to download your emails and find a new email provider".

A lot of people would have been very pissed off, even though it said 'beta'.

Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by arcbyte on Thursday April 13, 2023 @09:00AM (#35554732)
As I remember, it would have been very odd for them to do that in 2008 or 2009 when it was so immensley popular. But that was 4 or 5 year into it's life, well beyond the typical lifetime of Googles products.

Them shutting it down in 2005 or 2006 would have been annoying or disappointing like the shutdown of Google Wave but understandable.

It's all about brand expectations. Google is synonymous with unreliability because they don't have another brand to shoulder that association. It used to be "Beta" but no longer.

Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by hn_throwaway_99 on Thursday April 13, 2023 @10:52AM (#35556376)
The point is that their "release stage" marking was always fantasy land. Yes, I would be pissed if they had shut down GMail after 4 years, regardless of whether it was marked "Beta", because by that point it had a ton of users and clearly a ton of investment.

A big problem is that nobody believes their designations anyway. GMail was in beta for years when it was obviously a mature product, while "Of course we're investing a ton in Stadia..." only to shut it down a couple months later.

Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by cptaj on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:51AM (#35554610)
I think its about copping out of any responsibility.

Sure, go ahead. But the market will take notice if you do that.

Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by kmlx on Thursday April 13, 2023 @10:17AM (#35555831)
right, that too. but i prefer the honesty of having the “beta” label than the lack of it.
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by amenghra on Thursday April 13, 2023 @10:18AM (#35555858)
It’s impossible to go back in time and tell, but I bet lots of companies were opting for Microsoft Exchange/Web Outlook around 2007-2008, because Gmail was advertised as beta.

If they had removed the beta label sooner, they might have attracted businesses to GSuite sooner?

It’s a fine line to walk: you want to iterate quickly on one hand but some users need stability on the other.

Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by voytec on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:04AM (#35554127)
Yeah, with unlimited storage for life. Acquiring userbase with empty promises is their M.O.
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by wolrah on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:47AM (#35554563)
When was Gmail ever sold as unlimited? When it came out the big deal was that it offered 1GB, which absolutely destroyed the 5-10MB most free providers were offering at the time.

I recall a time where they were raising the limit constantly and even advertised that fact, that for most users your available space was going to increase faster than you could use it, but there was always a limit somewhere.

Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by voytec on Thursday April 13, 2023 @09:10AM (#35554870)
Wasn't it marketed as unlimited during invite-only beta?
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by lolinder on Thursday April 13, 2023 @09:48AM (#35555408)
No, 1GB was the starting point and was considered insane at the time. Then they eventually added a counter where the storage space grew all the time. They finally capped that out—maybe that's what you're thinking of?
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by voytec on Thursday April 13, 2023 @11:12AM (#35556711)
My bad. I misremembered.
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by wolrah on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:44PM (#35564183)
It was almost 20 years ago at this point, easy mistake to make.
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by thfuran on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:48AM (#35554574)
Wasn't it originally 1 GB? Then they doubled it on April fools one year and started increasing it from there.
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by ssdspoimdsjvv on Thursday April 13, 2023 @09:00AM (#35554725)
It even had a counter that was continuously incrementing (at the end by an incredibly low rate, but still)
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by prepend on Thursday April 13, 2023 @09:19AM (#35554986)
They used to have “google labs” but stopped it (haha) with some stupid explanation that it wasn’t needed any more because everything is a lab, or something like that.

And of course gmail was in beta for many years.

Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by bogwog on Thursday April 13, 2023 @09:32AM (#35555185)
Why would I invest in games/hardware for Stadia if Google themselves admit that it might get shutdown at anytime?

Lying to consumers is the safer (short term) bet.

Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by camdenreslink on Thursday April 13, 2023 @09:38AM (#35555267)
Stadia presumably would not have the experimental label because it was such a large investment.
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by rvnx on Thursday April 13, 2023 @10:00AM (#35555575)
They did something nice, instead of leaving the users with a brick, they refunded all users who bought Stadia products through official channels.

(sadly, to get official distribution, you need to be part of the "worldwide deployment" of Google products, and it's often a lie that actually menas "we deployed in many large countries except yours")

Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by ortusdux on Thursday April 13, 2023 @09:39AM (#35555276)
When Gmail finally left beta after 4+ years it had well over 100m users. Some argued that the beta label slowed early adoption, while others felt that it allowed more leniency with regards to problems and downtime. I could see members of the first group have a lingering desire to avoid new products getting stuck in beta.
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by lolinder on Thursday April 13, 2023 @09:53AM (#35555490)
I honestly think that a lot of these side projects should be released under a different brand name. Kind of like how GM has different brands for their luxury cars, or Disney had Touchstone Pictures for their less-child-friendly movies. If a project is one employee's 20% time or one manager's promotion project, it should be released under a different brand name. It can always be rebranded if it becomes an actual business priority.
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by ajsnigrutin on Thursday April 13, 2023 @10:11AM (#35555729)
They could just use some google name that clearly implies it's not a "main" (long-term) product, eg. "Google Labs", "Google Beta", etc. too, so you clearly know that it's a "toy" that might not exist anymore very soon. If they use eg. "Aviato" brand for some new product, people will expect more... and then get burned.. again.
Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by scarface74 on Thursday April 13, 2023 @10:10AM (#35555713)
That won’t help. How is the general audience suppose to know the difference between “experimental” and “beta”?

Maybe it’s important that they act like a grown up company and have some focus instead of throwing random shit up against the wall like apes in a zoo on a crack.

Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by agentdrtran on Thursday April 13, 2023 @10:21AM (#35555896)
they did this alrady with Tables, they labeled it an area120 project. they really need to do this for more stuff

https://tables.area120.google.com/u/0/about

Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by comte7092 on Thursday April 13, 2023 @11:19AM (#35556809)
> "This is a product we will give you many years notice and a migration path if we decide to get rid of it".

Is that even the standard procedure at google though? There are plenty of projects where they’ve unceremoniously pulled the plug with little notice, stadia is a glaring example (though to googles credit, they did provide some refunds)

Re:Google's 2023 Shutdown Spree: 6 Products Pulled in Just 4... by sanderjd on Thursday April 13, 2023 @01:11PM (#35558701)
Yeah but what will actually happen (has already happened) is just a lot fewer (to none) experimental projects.

That's a bit of a bummer, but probably fine. Just one of those things about working at a grown up company rather than a scrappy upstart.