News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Writer wants to make Portal 3, but Valve's 'flat structur... by Waterluvian on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @08:02PM (#35533388)
I think Valve suffers from what Blizzard suffers: they got so insanely profitable with one product that the games they’re known for became a distraction.

It seems counterintuitive: if there’s money to be had, go get it. But there’s a cognitive load and time sink at the senior management levels. Why bother us with this idea for a game that represents 1% of our annual profit if successful?

I feel a possible answer to this is to create a “prestige” studio that is more focused on fortifying your brand rather than profit. And I feel that what’s needed is full autonomy. Blizzard or Valve can wholly own this studio, but there is no cross-resourcing. Hire a passionate team, give them IPs to tenderly care for, and then leave them the ^%#* alone.

Re:Writer wants to make Portal 3, but Valve's 'flat structur... by true_religion on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @08:28PM (#35533576)
I would argue that Valve is just not a games company anymore. They make a video game platform and that’s what the majority of the effort is spent on.

It’s like going to Google and wanting to only work on search. It’s an ads company.

Re:Writer wants to make Portal 3, but Valve's 'flat structur... by GauntletWizard on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @08:56PM (#35533754)
Google used to understand that the products were the product and the ads were a necessity to pay people. That the ads would be worthless without people coming back to use their services, and that that should be the primary goal.

That's been proven untrue by the MBAs and the market. Google no longer creates good products, but the ad dollars flow more and more. People still significantly use Google search.

I'm of the belief that that's purely inertia - That Google was so successful at it's products that even though they're losing steam fast, they're still good products for now, but that they're gonna see a steep dive soon and not be able to recover.

Re:Writer wants to make Portal 3, but Valve's 'flat structur... by unsupp0rted on Wednesday April 12, 2023 @03:02AM (#35535953)
I use Google Search because the results are superior to Bing or DuckDuckGo, across many instances during the day.

Or if they’re not superior they’re not inferior.

Whereas when I use other search engines I have the nagging feeling I’m missing better information on Google.

Re:Writer wants to make Portal 3, but Valve's 'flat structur... by cassianoleal on Wednesday April 12, 2023 @04:15AM (#35536466)
> when I use other search engines I have the nagging feeling I’m missing better information on Google.

Are you though?

I've been using DDG for years now as my primary search engine.

When I started, I used !g quite often precisely because of that feeling. These days I have a hard time even remembering to try it when a search is unfruitful.

The reason being that it became less and less useful, and these days even when I do remember trying it, it generally doesn't add anything useful to my results.

Re:Writer wants to make Portal 3, but Valve's 'flat structur... by Waterluvian on Wednesday April 12, 2023 @07:37AM (#35538046)
DDG has been a non-start for image searches. But for limited scope things like looking up software libraries (basically: I already know what I want) I’ve found it to be fine.
Re:Writer wants to make Portal 3, but Valve's 'flat structur... by afiori on Wednesday April 12, 2023 @05:41AM (#35537117)
It is better on mobile, but on desktop google.com gives almost a full page of ads before the first result.
Re:Writer wants to make Portal 3, but Valve's 'flat structur... by unsupp0rted on Wednesday April 12, 2023 @06:41AM (#35537568)
* * *
Re:Writer wants to make Portal 3, but Valve's 'flat structur... by hinkley on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @08:56PM (#35533752)
I like your idea of a prestige studio, but I think the reason prestige brands exist in consumer goods is because even the company needs a mental separation between 'them' and 'us'. Audi has to be separate from VW, Acura from Honda, otherwise the high margin/low volume brands and the penny pinchers get confused by each other an fuck everything up.

So it couldn't just be called Valve or Blizzard, it'd have to be called something else.

If they do it right though, some interesting things could come from it. VW's high end is always full of parts that started life on an Audi and they learned to make more cheaply over time.

Re:Writer wants to make Portal 3, but Valve's 'flat structur... by morkalork on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @10:49PM (#35534440)
I think Fox Searchlight would be a better comparison. Are they going to produce mass appeal blockbusters that rake in tons of revenue? Probably not. Are they going to totally dominate the awards scene? Absolutely. That's what Valve needs for its IP.