We cannot not wait until someone is objectively dangerous before using state power to constrain their liberty in the interests of other people’s security, because any other course of action is arbitrary tyranny.
> The mentally ill need to be treated when symptoms first start manifesting if we want to actually solve this problem.
If we need to force people into treatment at the moment symptoms of what might or might not be mental illness that may or may not eventually lead to objective danger to other people start manifesting to solve the problem, then the cost is simply too high and we shouldn’t solve the problem.
Not all dangers in society have a mitigation that is a net benefit. Just because it would be beneficial in hindsight in the specific cases where we know from later events that it would have developed into a manifest harm does not mean that you can ignore the cost of all the cases where that isn’t the case that you would have to sweep into the dragnet in order to apply a “when symptoms first start manifesting” rule as opposed to a “objective danger” rule.
Not true. There are nonviolent crimes that are still crimes and that you can still jail people for, and which the homeless commit lots of.
I'm not saying we should involuntarily commit everyone who shows some symptoms of mental illness. I'm saying we should aim to treat those people before it becomes necessary to commit them.
I mean that feels like it's dangerously treading close to "pre-crime". I feel like it doesn't take much to extend that logic to poor rural children whose mothers are raising them in urban gang-run areas. I mean I can see the germ of the idea, but it's ripe for abuse.
It does so, in theory, based on indicia of objective danger (and is not without deep and serious problems in when it does act, as well as when it does not.)
It very much does not support the position of taking action when there is neither crime nor objective danger.