News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by throwaway22032 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @11:14AM (#35526310)
In extreme cases mental illness manifests in violent behaviour, suicidal behaviour, etc.

Most of us, including those of us with mental illness (which is effectively everyone to some degree), don't want to live in a society in which antisocial individuals are permitted to "refuse" to be treated. Their victims do not have that same privilege.

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by bolanyo on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @11:43AM (#35526758)
How do you know that 'most of us' feel that way?

I definitely do want to live in such a society.

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by throwaway22032 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @11:46AM (#35526818)
The rule of law, and non-elective incarceration for violent behaviour, are about as old as time itself.

You can remove the laws if you like, societies will simply begin self-organizing around removing antisocial elements (or removing themselves from the situation e.g. downtown decay).

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by habinero on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:11PM (#35528049)
I just want to point out that we have several people in this thread talking about the blatant tyranny of being asked to wear a small face covering...

...while simultaneously advocating for the state to imprison and forcibly medicate others.

It's also interesting that you value "a nice downtown" more than "liberty".

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by throwaway22032 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:27PM (#35528286)
On the one hand, we have a perfectly functioning member of society being forced to wear a mask, when they don't even have a disease, for the sake of overly-anxious individuals.

On the other, we have someone who might decide to live in a random place in a tent, shit in the street, swing bricks in socks around on the trains etc.

I'm far more worried about the degenerates on my route from the train station than I ever was about coronavirus.

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by vkou on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:37PM (#35528409)
> I'm far more worried about the degenerates on my route from the train station than I ever was about coronavirus.

And I'm personally far more worried about the 'degenerates' who might get my immunocompromised grandfather sick, than the people I meet on my way to the bus stop.

Unlike the people refusing to vaccinate, he doesn't have a choice in his condition. He gets to live with the selfish, ignorant decisions made by others.

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by throwaway22032 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @02:53PM (#35529628)
No-one is proposing that all mentally ill people (effectively all people) are forcibly medicated.

Only those that are an acute danger to themselves and others, degrading the world around them on a non-statistical basis.

The alternative is to imprison them.

You are engaging in a strawman here.

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by habinero on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @03:32PM (#35530232)
Valuing a nice walk over human freedom, autonomy and dignity sure is an interesting choice for a person who claims to be moral.
Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by throwaway22032 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @06:38PM (#35532602)
Dignity sure is an interesting choice of word to use to describe ferals.
Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by vkou on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:35PM (#35528382)
> Most of us, including those of us with mental illness (which is effectively everyone to some degree), don't want to live in a society in which antisocial individuals are permitted to "refuse" to be treated. Their victims do not have that same privilege.

You're making an excellent case for mandatory vaccinations.

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by throwaway22032 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @02:59PM (#35529747)
In the case of mandatory vaccinations, the victims are few whereas the requirement is placed on many.

In the case of acute mental illness, the victims are many whereas the requirement is placed on few.

The situations are not comparable.

I think a more reasonable analogue would be that I am making the case for mandatory isolation for sick individuals.

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by vkou on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @03:09PM (#35529858)
> In the case of mandatory vaccinations, the victims are few whereas the requirement is placed on many.

> In the case of acute mental illness, the victims are many whereas the requirement is placed on few.

No. Mentally ill people harm far fewer people than preventable infectious diseases do. COVID killed over a million people in the US in three years, and seriously injured many, many more. How many deaths can you attribute to mentally ill people, that you'd like to forcibly treat in that time? A few dozen? A few hundred?

And the 'requirement' is far more onerous and invasive in the latter case. If mental illness could be cured with two shots and a day of discomfort, you might have a leg to stand on. It can't be, which is why mandating treatment is rife with abuses, and obvious moral and medical problems.

> The situations are not comparable.

They aren't comparable because the ROI of mandating vaccinations is much better than the ROI of mandating mental health treatment.

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by throwaway22032 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @03:12PM (#35529884)
There's about as much logic in what you're saying as "we lock up criminals, therefore we should require everyone to be vaccinated".

Regardless of the merits of vaccination, it's nonsensical to make this sort of analogy, and I have better things to do than engage with this.

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by vkou on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @03:48PM (#35530502)
It's an entirely apples to apples logical comparison. The problem is that you don't like what the 'mandate unwanted medical treatment for the benefit of society' garden path leads down towards.

You simply choose to not quantify the very real harm that unvaccinated people inflict on people around them. You assign it a value of zero, by calling it 'statistical'. It's illogical and irrational to do so, though. The harm is real, it's quantifiable, and people are suffering and dying from it.