News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hacker News Ranking Algorithm by cornholio on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:22AM (#35510794)
What would happen is that the olde accounts would accumulate "CommentRank" and the new users would always be sorted to the bottom. This is good for search, since we are looking for "the" answer, the site, a limited number of best pages for a topic etc., but it's quite bad for discussion; a bad take from Animats would forever be above a good comment from a greenhorn.
Re:Hacker News Ranking Algorithm by vignesh_warar on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:30AM (#35510830)
I thought about it while writing this post. It would be useful to have a decay factor for PageRank. In simple words, if someone wants to maintain their PR score, they need to actively engage in the HN community.
Re:Hacker News Ranking Algorithm by dsr_ on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:50AM (#35510939)
You can put epicycle around epicycle, but there's a lot of computational efficiency in a score which can be calculated from an integer and a timestamp.
Re:Hacker News Ranking Algorithm by buran77 on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:55AM (#35510964)
> if someone wants to maintain their PR score, they need to actively engage

Wouldn't that encourage people to "actively engage" even when they have nothing to say just to keep their score?

Goodhart's law comes into mind here. People who want to stay relevant on this site will take your measure as their target. There's no system that can't be gamed if you know the rules. But the more "rock solid" you try to make those rules, the more you embed intrinsic discrimination between participants. You put "Proof of Work" in the rules and you alienate newcomers while all the rest do "busywork".

Your own comments and submissions would sink like a stone because you didn't engage enough, regardless of how interesting your points are.

Re:Hacker News Ranking Algorithm by vignesh_warar on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:04AM (#35511015)
I think this part of the post answers your question.

> Will I ever publicly write about how HN ranks posts if I am Dang (HN moderator)? No, because Pagerank can be manipulated by people despite its reputation. In fact, Pagerank is being exploited for years. Moreover, there are financial incentives for companies to get on the first page in HN.

Re:Hacker News Ranking Algorithm by buran77 on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:12AM (#35511056)
> Will I ever publicly write about how HN ranks posts if I am Dang (HN moderator)? No

Lack of transparency is not a solution, and certainly not one that will sell well in a place where "security by obscurity" is disdained and open source cherished. It's particularly bad when you're dealing with a high profile site filled with intelligent people who would most likely make short work of reverse engineering just enough of the algorithm to understand how it works.

Re:Hacker News Ranking Algorithm by bookofjoe on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:55AM (#35511289)
With 100% certainty dang ("Dang") read this comment.
Re:Hacker News Ranking Algorithm by vignesh_warar on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:08AM (#35511368)
I would be really happy to know his thoughts.
Re:Hacker News Ranking Algorithm by bookofjoe on Monday April 10, 2023 @02:43PM (#35515801)
Re:Hacker News Ranking Algorithm by lenocinor on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:05PM (#35517963)
You can write [email protected] . I’ve chatted with dang on that email address several times.