News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Timon3 on Saturday April 08, 2023 @10:12AM (#35493313)
Rice cultivation hasn't been a factor in climate for all time, only relatively recently. The increase in methane can have an accumulating warming effect. Think about it like this - the amount of rice fields is the derivative of climate change. If you increase the amount of rice fields once and don't decrease it, climate change will slowly but surely rise, even if rice fields don't increase.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by xyzzyz on Saturday April 08, 2023 @10:57AM (#35493804)
No, that’s not the case, because the methane doesn’t accumulate. If you increase the amount of rice under cultivation, the methane content in atmosphere will stabilize after around 20 years, and after that there will be no more climate change resulting from the rice fields.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Timon3 on Saturday April 08, 2023 @11:24AM (#35494148)
I'm not saying the methane accumulates, but the additional energy in the whole earth system does. Every year with additional methane has an effect. If you have no rice fields, then rice fields for a couple of years, and then again no rice fields, you'll have increased methane levels for those years. If you compared that earth to another one without those years of increased levels, the one without would be less warm.

Remember: climate change is not a derivative, it's an integral.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by xyzzyz on Saturday April 08, 2023 @12:06PM (#35494633)
No, the energy doesn’t accumulate in Earth over time. Disregarding the energy of radioactive decay within Earth, the Earth is in steady state with respect to energy. All energy it receives from the Sun is radiated away promptly. The greenhouse effect works by delaying this radiation. The more the radiation is delayed by, the more energy is buffered in steady state. Make no mistake though: all of the energy from the Sun is radiated away rather quickly.

> If you compared that earth to another one without those years of increased levels, the one without would be less warm.

No, after the methane from the fields decays to CO2, both would be the same.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Timon3 on Saturday April 08, 2023 @12:31PM (#35494939)
> All energy it receives from the Sun is radiated away promptly. The greenhouse effect works by delaying this radiation. The more the radiation is delayed by, the more energy is buffered in steady state. Make no mistake though: all of the energy from the Sun is radiated away rather quickly.

This is easily disproven. The Earth does trap heat - we can measure this, it's called the Earth Energy Imbalance. This imbalance has been rising since more greenhouse gases were introduced: https://www.nasa.gov/feature/langley/joint-nasa-noaa-study-f...

The amount trapped is rising because we retain the same input longer. A fraction of the total heat is radiated away (not all of it, and not "rather quickly"). If that fraction drops more heat will be trapped.

Now you have a system with additional energy due to additional greenhouse gases. Over time the gases will reduce, but the radiation is still only a fraction of the total heat! Of course over time this will very slowly trend back towards the same temperature, but even when the gases themselves have returned to previous levels, the additional heat will take a number of years to be radiated away.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Retric on Saturday April 08, 2023 @01:23PM (#35495523)
That’s true, but we’ve been cultivating rice for thousands of years. When people talk about returning the earth to pre industrial levels that’s a world with significant rice cultivation going back long enough to account for such differences.

The global energy imbalance is simply lag before temperature’s equilibrium, when you turn up the heat in your house it takes longer to heat your fireplace than a wood door. That same effect takes longer on the scale of the earth but it’s an exponential decay. Compared to the history of rice cultivation you very quickly get to millions of a degree difference in surface temperatures. We just keep adding ever more greenhouse gasses.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Timon3 on Saturday April 08, 2023 @01:39PM (#35495692)
> That’s true, but we’ve been cultivating rice for thousands of years.

How much rice did we previously cultivate, and how many of those fields were flooded? Around 1900 the world population was around 2 billion, so I feel confident in assuming that we've since strongly increased the amount of farms. As such I don't see how this matters. Cultivation is not a boolean state.

> The global energy imbalance is simply lag before temperature’s equilibrium, when you turn up the heat in your house it takes longer to heat your fireplace than a wood door. That same effect takes longer on the scale of the earth but it’s an exponential decay.

Yes, this is what I've been saying. Increasing the amount of methane in the atmosphere by increasing rice production will lead to an increased temperature even after you stop.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Retric on Saturday April 08, 2023 @04:15PM (#35497154)
> Around 1900 the world population was around 2 billion, so I feel confident in assuming that we've since strongly increased the amount of farms

Actually not so much, due to vastly increased agricultural output per acre the tendency is to have less acres under cultivation. https://www.statista.com/statistics/196104/total-area-of-lan...

Further agriculture has also reduced quite a bit of methane production by draining swamps etc. So it’s difficult to do direct comparisons even just back in 1900.

> Increasing the amount of methane in the atmosphere by increasing rice production will lead to an increased temperature even after you stop.

That’s true of CO2 across the next few decades but not methane because it breaks down so fast. Assuming net zero CO2 the lag would be in the other direction where it would get colder for several years after you stopped.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Timon3 on Saturday April 08, 2023 @04:53PM (#35497509)
> Actually not so much, due to vastly increased agricultural output per acre the tendency is to have less acres under cultivation.

Your source shows data for America between 2000 and 2022. Why do you think that is a good source for the topic at hand?

> Further agriculture has also reduced quite a bit of methane production by draining swamps etc. So it’s difficult to do direct comparisons even just back in 1900.

There is no reason to do so, my argument is not affected by it in any way.

> That’s true of CO2 across the next few decades but not methane because it breaks down so fast.

No, breakdown time doesn't affect anything, since I'm specifically talking about the time after it broke down. If you understood my comments differently, try re-reading them in that light.

> Assuming net zero CO2 the lag would be in the other direction where it would get colder for several years after you stopped.

Am I understanding you correctly - you believe that temperature is like a pendulum, where after a period with increased greenhouse gases, it will somehow swing to be colder than it would have been without that period? Why do you think so, and how do you believe this to work from a thermodynamics perspective?

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Retric on Sunday April 09, 2023 @10:43AM (#35503163)
> Why do you think that is a good source for the topic at hand?

The obvious downward line even as population and farm output increased prove your argument was completely false. That’s as much as I care to prove. Do some damn research.

> Am I understanding you correctly - you believe that temperature is like a pendulum, where after a period with increased greenhouse gases, it will somehow swing to be colder than it would have been without that period? Why do you think so, and how do you believe this to work from a thermodynamics perspective?

Hell no. I am saying if the level of greenhouse gasses drops there will be lag in the other direction. There’s nothing special about the direction of lag it’s simply a delay before equilibrium.

Clearly you haven’t understood what I said or the topic at hand and need to do some actual research before you keep spouting more nonsense.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by jholman on Sunday April 09, 2023 @05:10PM (#35506500)
Yikes, you (singular) just got rather uncivil. Such a shame, as you (plural) were doing so well.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Retric on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:03PM (#35516040)
I don’t consider someone being disingenuous as being civil in a discussion.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Timon3 on Sunday April 09, 2023 @06:37PM (#35507166)
> The obvious downward line even as population and farm output increased prove your argument was completely false. That’s as much as I care to prove. Do some damn research.

"The obvious downward line" is not relevant since it's for a time period that is only starting to affect todays climate. I was previously talking about time periods which would already be affecting the climate today. What if through the use of modern machinery and fertilizer the land use started trending down slightly in the 80s, and rose rapidly before then? We don't know, which is why your statistic is fully irrelevant to this discussion. I'm not interested in simplifying complex systems like historical agriculture to "line goes down now, line must have been going down before".

Maybe "do some damn research" that looks at the content in the context of the discussion.

> Hell no. I am saying if the level of greenhouse gasses drops there will be lag in the other direction. There’s nothing special about the direction of lag it’s simply a delay before equilibrium.

I really, really think you should try to re-read my previous comments. This doesn't make any sense. Let's play through it with numbers - maybe you'll show me I've been a complete idiot.

Let's define a starting point of greenhouse gases and temperature, both start at 0. We are in an equilibrium. Now we increase greenhouse gases to 1, and after some time temperature will also increase to 1 (arbitrary values). Then we decrease greenhouse gases to 0 (previous equilibrium). It will take some time until the temperature goes back to 0.

Referring back to the comment I was replying to: where do we get colder compared to a reference earth without increased gases?

That's my whole argument, it's what I've been writing the whole time. The increased greenhouse gases lead to a higher temperature, which will (until it goes back to equilibrium) be increased compared to if there was no increase in greenhouse gases, and it will stay increased for a while after greenhouse gases are at equilibrium.

What exactly are you arguing against? It seems you're taking stabs at whatever sentence you feel is incorrect, but I haven't seen a coherent argument.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Retric on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:04PM (#35516052)
More complaining zero research, why I not surprised…

> where do we get colder compared to a reference earth without increased gases?

Wow. Suppose it’s fall and someone says “the days are getting colder.” Do you assume it’s in relation to some arbitrary point thousands of years ago or last month?

Context is often implied in the written word, and you seem to have issues following normal conventions. I don’t mean this as an insult, but there’s probably some adult education classes that you might find helpful.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Timon3 on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:50PM (#35517240)
If you're not arguing for that, what exactly are you arguing for? What have I said that you disagree with? I've tried laying out my argument multiple times very clearly, but you're choosing to engage in ad-hominems instead. Seriously, what is that last paragraph, if not a giant insult?

I'm trying to have a normal and calm conversation. If you're not capable of responding in kind, don't respond. You're going on about how I'm not doing research, while you're not even responding to my criticism of your previosu statistic. Seriously, if you think that statistic had any value for this conversation: then yes, I'm fully incapable of doing what you consider research.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by NotYourLawyer on Saturday April 08, 2023 @11:23AM (#35494141)
Yeah, but it will stabilize at a higher level than it would otherwise have been.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Retric on Saturday April 08, 2023 @01:34PM (#35495641)
10,000 years isn’t relatively recently on the scales of human civilization nor how quickly the climate feedback loops operate.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Timon3 on Saturday April 08, 2023 @01:42PM (#35495731)
Okay? I don't see how this is relevant? All I was saying was that there was a point in time without rice cultivation, and another one with rice cultivation. The point with cultivation has higher levels of methane. Even if you were to return to the point without cultivation, the period with cultivation will have lead to an increased temperature.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Retric on Saturday April 08, 2023 @04:03PM (#35497040)
It’s relevant because you said relatively recently then chose a completely arbitrary yet undefined point. Once you start talking about periods before written or oral records we have little basis for comparison to say if it was good or not. Why not chose the last ice age, or even periods with higher than current global temperature as the baseline?
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Timon3 on Saturday April 08, 2023 @04:45PM (#35497426)
I stay by that. On a climate scale, scaled-up rice production has started a short time ago - which is why I wrote my initial comment: looking at the climate right now and extrapolating that current rice farming has no impact on climate change is illogical.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Retric on Sunday April 09, 2023 @01:53PM (#35504916)
There is no “long term climate scale.” Climate responds relatively quickly to changes.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by Timon3 on Sunday April 09, 2023 @06:29PM (#35507098)
Sorry, but what exactly are you arguing for? Of course you can view the climate at different time scales, and of course you can refer to those time scales by colloquial terms. Climate shows cyclic behavior at the time scales I was referring to: https://www.fs.usda.gov/ccrc/education/climate-primer/natura...

You could have asked for what I was referring to, but instead you chose to jump in with your definitions. Have you had conversational success with this approach?