News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yann LeCun and Andrew Ng: Why the 6-Month AI Pause Is a B... by echelon on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:29PM (#35485959)
We haven't seen even an inkling of this happening. It's all hypothetical, coming from vivid imaginations.

It reminds me of Y2K hysteria.

When old jobs die, new jobs arise. That has always been the case, and I haven't seen any evidence of that ending.

Re:Yann LeCun and Andrew Ng: Why the 6-Month AI Pause Is a B... by TheMode on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:39PM (#35486070)
What new job will arise? The ones requiring more education? The barrier to enter the economy cannot indefinitely grow, do we want every single human to become an AI developer or a researcher?

The problem is that humans aren't getting specially smarter as generations go, but technology continue to grow

Re:Yann LeCun and Andrew Ng: Why the 6-Month AI Pause Is a B... by than3 on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:45PM (#35486134)
Your response's argument is a classic example of survivor bias.

It also ignores a growing body of evidence.

If new jobs arise as you say in the same amounts, why is it that young people are having such a hard time finding gainful employment these days?

Take a look at the statistics, you'll find as some already have, that the job pool has been shrinking, and older workers who have more experience out-compete younger workers for entry level jobs because the cost to train (is high), and production is lower in workers with no experience than those with experience.

The only indicators we would have that this is happening, just like inflation, are lagging indicators.

By the time you know it is happening, its then too late to do anything. That's why this problem will probably kill us all. We as a species historically do not handle cascade failures well because we don't perceive the danger until its too late.

Its a problem where our natural biases work against us. Its normal to just discount problems we have no context, which is why the out-of-context problem is so dangerous.

Do you think the native people's of the Carribean thought there was danger from white sails of Columbus ships?

Re:Yann LeCun and Andrew Ng: Why the 6-Month AI Pause Is a B... by dragonwriter on Friday April 07, 2023 @06:07PM (#35487627)
> If new jobs arise as you say in the same amounts, why is it that young people are having such a hard time finding gainful employment these days?

By what measure? Youth unemployment is right now around its lowest level in…quite a long time. [0]

[0] https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/youth-unemploymen...

Re:Yann LeCun and Andrew Ng: Why the 6-Month AI Pause Is a B... by than3 on Friday April 07, 2023 @07:57PM (#35488761)
Unemployment in the US Has always been a flawed metric in recent history.

BLS data has been manipulated and methodology changed to always paint the rosiest picture for policymakers.

The shadowstats website has continued with the older more accurate methodology where it shows a more realistic view, when it can.

US data for unemployment has been fundamentally flawed for decades. In essence, the methodology stops counting people looking for work when they have been unable to find work after some amount of time. If you aren't actively looking for work or recently had work, you aren't counted. Actively looking doesn't mean interviews, it means being registered in a work program, which has a large number of requirements and competition.

The resolution foundation has several good analysis of multiple countries that show this trend.

If you want more specific details than that, I'd suggest "The Pinch" by Willett. It has many credible references, supporting this at the back (too many to list).

Where other similarly themed books like "The Theft of a Decade", offer no more than opinion, this covers what you are looking for with gratuitous references.

Re:Yann LeCun and Andrew Ng: Why the 6-Month AI Pause Is a B... by dragonwriter on Friday April 07, 2023 @09:48PM (#35489608)
You…didn’t answer the question. By what measure is it true “young people are having such a hard time finding gainful employment these days?”
Re:Yann LeCun and Andrew Ng: Why the 6-Month AI Pause Is a B... by than3 on Saturday April 08, 2023 @02:45PM (#35496329)
You clearly either didn't read, or didn't comprehend what I wrote if you think that.

There is nothing I can do about that.

Re:Yann LeCun and Andrew Ng: Why the 6-Month AI Pause Is a B... by lewhoo on Friday April 07, 2023 @04:51PM (#35486807)
Except during other times of turmoil people I think were generally able to predict what types of jobs are expected to flourish. The mining industry, metallurgy, transportation, constructing maintaining and operating machinery etc. With AI all I see is a slogan - it will create jobs. Furthermore, with machines replacing physical workers we had a sprout of more sophisticated jobs. If the analogy holds then shouldn't we expect physical work to become more prominent ? I maintain the view that if openai or any other company achieves their goal in some way, meaning not necessarily AGI but a competent level of intelligence that can operate unsupervised the net value of jobs taken against jobs created will be lean heavily to the former.