News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by komali2 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:54AM (#35453328)
> first concern is how it will affect criminals

My first concern is how it will affect people the police historically over-target. That means black people and LGBT people. I'm re-reading my comment and I think I alluded to that, so I'm a little concerned that you said "how it will affect criminals".

> the police and the DA office have essentially legalized many forms of crime by refusing to prosecute people

This is a broad oversimplification of the situation in SF. I keep hearing this myth from people that don't live in SF that the police have been, like, abolished or something, but in reality no politician comes anywhere close to touching police abolitionist rhetoric.

In reality the cops absolutely hated the last DA and it seems they started sucking at their jobs on purpose as a result. The new DA they seem to like a lot more. Regardless, blame always seems to deflect off the cops and onto the nearest politician when it comes to basically anything in SF.

Replies to you are discussing how "crime is legal" in SF and I really have no idea what this could mean. It sounds like fox news gobblygook to me.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by TechBro8615 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:34AM (#35453888)
> My first concern is how it will affect people the police historically over-target

What's worse, some people feeling unsafe around police, or everyone feeling unsafe around everyone?

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by komali2 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:41AM (#35464993)
This is a false dichotomy.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by TechBro8615 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:07AM (#35467229)
You're right, it's not everyone; the criminals aren't feeling unsafe.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by komali2 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @10:58AM (#35469207)
No, your false dichotomy was supposing that we must have some arrangement of people (historically in the usa this means black people) feel unsafe around police in order for the rest of us to feel safe in society.

It's not just a false dichotomy, it's illogical. If a given set of people doesn't feel safe around the police, they don't feel safe in society. They are us, unless you're willing to dehumanize them, so therefore a world where we don't feel safe around the police is actually your second case, where we don't feel safe at all.

I click through this thread desperate for a conservative position that isn't teetering on a stack of rhetorical fallacies or cognitive biases. Are you able to provide one?

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by TechBro8615 on Saturday April 08, 2023 @10:07PM (#35499473)
I thought I was providing one, in the form of the utilitarian argument that it's better for some people to be scared of police than for everyone to be scared of each other. You can disagree with utilitarian ethics, but it's not a rhetorical fallacy to promote them, and certainly not when presenting them as "the least bad option."
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by tdehnel on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:59AM (#35454333)
Some groups commit more crime than others. So we should expect to see more arrests for certain groups. See Table 8: https://bjs.ojp.gov/content/pub/pdf/revcoa18.pdf

As for SF politicians, how about this SF politician, Hillary Ronen, who is the elected Supervisor of District 9 (the Mission) which has seen some of the worst crime increases in the city?

"I want to make it clear that I believe strongly in defunding the police and reducing the number of officers on our force."

"1. Significant cuts to SFPD’s budget that will meaningfully start off a multi-year process to defund and reimagine policing in San Francisco. 2. A reduction in the number of officers and command staff."

https://twitter.com/HillaryRonen/status/1295172855722725378

Regarding "crime being legal" - I invite you to come to my local Safeway. We can stand by the checkout and watch someone walk out with a backpack full of goods every 5 minutes. No one does anything about it. Because even if they were arrested, the DA wouldn't prosecute, and the judge wouldn't give a meaningful punishment.

We also have a law against public camping in SF. Yet many streets have so many tents you have to cross to the other side, or walk in the street to get around.

Just 2 examples of crime being practically legal.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by komali2 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @07:03PM (#35461678)
> Some groups commit more crime than others.

I'm just so tired that this position is still held by people. It's just so easy to see the issue one can't help but wonder why you're preferring to believe the inherently racist take.

No, certain races do not commit more crimes than other ones; certain races get convicted and arrested more than other ones.

The evidence bears this out in reality. The racist interpretation is strongly incorrect. The data supports my position, not yours. Why do you hold the racist position anyway?

In random stops and searches, contraband is found more often on white people, than black people. Why do more black people go to jail? Easy, systemic racism. What possible other conclusion could you reasonably arrive at?

The wikipedia article on race and crime in the usa is an excellent summation. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_crime_in_the_United...

Regarding Ronen, handwaving vague fear mongering about police abolitionism isn't good enough. I'm forced to throw buckets of analysis into a comment for the millionth time to counter a racist interpretation of crime statistics, but you get to drop a tweet and say you saw someone steal food once and thus argue that progressive solutions to reducing crime are all naive and stupid? Nah. Do your footwork. See if your position has any actual strength.

Anyway, the budget for sfpd is already high, and has only gone up year on year. The police haven't been defunded.

Lol at the comment about public camping. Dare I even ask what you prefer the city does with homeless people?