News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by istjohn on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:32AM (#35453014)
In a democracy, you are the government. What we see today in SF is the consequence of decades of hostility to construction and growth from the residents of SF.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by ilikecakeandpie on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:55AM (#35453341)
In the US, that's not entirely true. There's acts of voter suppression and gerrymandering that have been rampant for what feels like forever and persist today.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by Mountain_Skies on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:19AM (#35453672)
Is that what's happening in San Francisco?
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by throwayyy479087 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:44AM (#35454049)
I agree. The GOP gerrymandering SF so that they have complete control of city council is obviously the problem here. /s

There are no GOP members in City government, and haven't been for a long, long time. This is the result of progressive policies. Accept that or this will continue.

https://sfbgarchive.48hills.org/sfbgarchive/2014/08/05/last-...

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by anon291 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:54AM (#35454228)
Americans have a major fetish for blaming the GOP. In my city of Portland which has many similar problems to sf, I constantly hear the reasons things are so bad is the GOP. What causes this kind of analysis to become so widespread?
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by throwayyy479087 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @10:27AM (#35454824)
People don't like to believe that problems are of their own making. You legalize meth, then your city fills up with people using meth - that's not the problem of the GOP. There's approximately no Republicans in Seattle, SF, or Portland - the problem is progressivism.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by ilikecakeandpie on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:17PM (#35457431)
>I agree. The GOP gerrymandering SF so that they have complete control of city council is obviously the problem here. /s

Hey now, I was addressing this part of the comment "In a democracy, you are the government"

I am speaking as someone who lives in a red state where our abortion laws have been rolled back and have seen the impact of the gerrymandering first hand. This is the result of conservative policies and will likely have a negative effect on our state; whether by an exodus of those who don't see the point in staying or by increasing poverty for forced birth for those who can't afford to skirt the laws

>This is the result of progressive policies. Accept that or this will continue.

I don't live in SF so I can't speak with any authority to how much worse it has become. I can say that my city's murder rate is almost 50% higher than SF while being much smaller. From what I've read, SF is at least trying something in terms of harm reduction instead of just outright criminalizing or ignoring, which is what we're do and isn't working.

I don't have the answers and it seems to be a difficult task to come up with plans without violating a person's autonomy.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by throwayyy479087 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:18PM (#35457455)
This post is about a murder in SF. Not about your home state. It's got nothing to do with the GOP.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by ilikecakeandpie on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:28PM (#35457591)
I did not mention the GOP initially. You did in your reply and I replied to you. As mentioned earlier, I was addressing this part of the comment "In a democracy, you are the government"

No one forced you to interact with me and I think we're both worse off that you chose to do so.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by TechBro8615 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @10:06AM (#35454480)
I can maybe understand the premise that fewer houses means more homelessness. Although I'm skeptical that it's a direct cause, and undoubtedly many homeless people in SF did not become homeless in SF, but migrated there after they lost their home or became addicted elsewhere.

It's a commonly promoted trope to blame all of SF's problems on wealth inequality and the housing market. But it could be an oversimplification that hand-waves a difficult discussion, which only ends up exacerbating the problem.

Can you articulate how housing policy leads to drug addiction, open air drug markets, high rates of property crime, and general non-enforcement of criminality?

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by istjohn on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @02:12PM (#35458278)
You're skeptical housing shortages cause homelessness? How could it be otherwise?

To address your question, it's incredibly difficult to cope with mental illness or overcome addiction while homeless. It's also difficult to hold down a job. Drug use and joblessness lead to property crime and open air drug markets.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by TechBro8615 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:47PM (#35459465)
> You're skeptical housing shortages cause homelessness? How could it be otherwise?

Well, people could become homeless outside of San Francisco (possibly after becoming addicted to drugs), and then migrate to San Francisco. Even in the hypothetical scenario where houses cost nothing but are unavailable in San Francisco, it would seem misleading to blame that SF housing shortage for the homelessness of someone who migrated there after becoming homeless.

Is there data available for how many people currently homeless in San Francisco became homeless in San Francisco? That is, where did they last rent property? I'm not being snarky; I'm curious what the percentages are like. My guess is that a significant majority of homeless people in San Francisco were previously renting in another location, then got evicted, and then eventually moved to SF.

> it's incredibly difficult to cope with mental illness or overcome addiction while homeless. It's also difficult to hold down a job.

Yes, that's true, once you're homeless. My question is about how the housing shortage in San Francisco causes homelessness. That is, how does housing policy in a jurisdiction lead to people becoming homeless after they were previously living in a property within that jurisdiction?

Also, consider what might make a city an appealing destination for someone who becomes homeless while addicted to drugs. If your heroin addiction gets you kicked out of your apartment in Reno, and you're looking to score some smack, why not catch a $15 Greyhound to San Francisco? It's an easy place to buy drugs, and it's a city well known for its citizens and authorities tolerating people openly using drugs and sleeping on the street. And when you run out of money, you can smash a few car windows until you find some cash, then walk a few blocks to exchange it for drugs from your nearest heroin dealer.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by JetSpiegel on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:48PM (#35462619)
The logical consequence of this argument is for San Francisco to secede from the Union and build a wall around the city to stop foreign homeless people from coming in. And blowing up BART too.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by TechBro8615 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:57PM (#35462687)
Alternatively, the SFPD could start arresting people for committing crimes, the DA could start charging them for crimes, and the judges could start sentencing them for crimes. And the legislators can make sleeping on the street a crime. Make it impossible to get drugs without significant risk. Discourage drug addicts from immigrating to SF as if it's some kind of heroin haven where they can live, sleep, shit and do drugs on the street.

Or just let the inevitable earthquake take care of it.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by nwienert on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:16AM (#35464056)
This is the simple and obvious solution that works but for some reason liberalism post-Clinton took a shift towards being not just less pro law and order, but actively anti.

Housing is certainly an ingredient in the soup. So is inequality. And corruption. A culture that is anti-family, consumerist, pro-drug, individualist.

What else? There's so many factors. A lack of cohesive identity. The American attitude of narcissism and the fuck-you mentality. A lack of willingness to call out ghetto behavior as bad. Neutered teachers and schools preaching that all things are equally good and gradually lowering standards. Entire generations of families that basically feed into gangs. A lack of government ability/will to break up gangs. Incessant, unmitigated advertising. Government controlled media serving white-washed bullshit. Liberalism gone off the rails, generally.

It's a mess.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by istjohn on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:44AM (#35467598)
The Supreme Court ruled that you can't criminalize sleeping on the street if there isn't shelter space available, so your dystopia in which people are jailed for existing in proximity to you without being rich isn't going to happen.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by TechBro8615 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @09:34AM (#35468107)
Seems like SF is doing fine with their current dystopia.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by istjohn on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:37AM (#35467533)
A 2019 survey found that 70% of people homeless in San Francisco in 2019 reported most recently becoming homeless while living in San Francisco: 22% came from another county within California, and 8% came from another state[1].

Housing policy decreases supply which increases costs beyond the means of low-wage workers.

1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_the_San_Fran....

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by TechBro8615 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @09:50AM (#35468287)
Interesting, thanks for the link. I have to admit, 70% is a lot higher than I would have guessed. Here's the cited survey (PDF) [0] which has a lot of well-presented data.

Some other interesting points I noticed:

> Nearly half (48%) of youth survey respondents reported living in San Francisco when they most recently became homeless. Thirty-nine percent (39%) reported living in another county in California and 14% reported living out of state.

So 53% of youth respondents became homeless outside of San Francisco, compared to only 30% of overall respondents. This skew possibly indicates a trend of younger people becoming homeless outside of San Francisco and moving there. That also implies the number of homeless people in San Francisco will continue to increase.

> Previous living arrangements: 30% Home Owned or Rented by Self or Partner, 33% With Friends or Family.

This implies there's a gradual transition to homelessness. Maybe there's a chance for early intervention when someone starts living with friends or family.

> Primary Cause of Homelessness (Self-reported): 25% Lost Job, 18% Alcohol or Drug Use, 13% Eviction

Unfortunately it's hard to separate these causes, since e.g. alcohol or drug use can lead to lost job. But again, 18% citing drug use is lower than I would have expected. I wonder how many non-addicts become addicts while homeless.

[0] https://hsh.sfgov.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/2019HIRDRep...

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by jollyllama on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:58AM (#35456274)
>you are the government

Maybe if you're a moneyed donor.